Discussion
One of the aims of Granta.com is to encourage discussion and debate. As such, we welcome your comments on the pieces we publish on this site.
In order to enjoy the full benefits of Granta.com, including its comment facilities, you will need to create a Granta account.
All comments are moderated. Offensive or abusive comments will be deleted as will unrelated, self-promotional or commerical links or spam. We reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.


Grace6
Broken Star
8/7/2011
View commentI loved this article. The narrative voice was so accomplished throughout. Great read.
Grace6
The Encirclement
8/7/2011
View commentThis comment has been removed by the moderators.
Grace6
The Encirclement
8/7/2011
View commentThis comment has been removed by the moderators.
Grace6
A Sign of Weakness
8/7/2011
View commentGreat point by Denis. Very thoughtful.
Grace6
A Sign of Weakness
8/7/2011
View commentGreat point by Denis. Very thoughtful.
Grace6
Netherley
8/7/2011
View comment"Another cliché: you never really leave." The best opening line ever!!!
Grace6
Netherley
8/7/2011
View comment"Another cliché: you never really leave." The best opening line ever!!!
Grace6
All I Know About Gertrude Stein
4/7/2011
View commentMrs. Winterson has a way with words that touch the soul on many different levels. Amazing!
Grace6
A Sign of Weakness
4/7/2011
View commentVery extraordinary Dennis! I hope to see more from this author.
Grace6
17 Melbourne Road
4/7/2011
View commentHaha, thought of Brute and Old Spice. That's funny!
Grace6
Capital Gains
4/7/2011
View commentI agree with biswadip in that "I hope, in his forthcoming book Rana would offer some idea about the 'other' Delhi which is still untouched by the corrupt lot."
Grace6
Capital Gains
4/7/2011
View commentThis is such a great piece about Delhi and captures the feeling and economics of the great city.
Grace6
How to Write about Africa
4/7/2011
View commentI understand that Africa isn't like this everywhere. Some of this is a bit exaggerated to make it more entertaining.
Grace6
How to Write about Africa
4/7/2011
View commentPeople, please remember this is a creative writing article meant for entertainment.
Grace6
The Visiting Child
4/7/2011
View commentOk, I just read it again and now I understand the points the author attempted to make. Much better now.
Grace6
The Visiting Child
4/7/2011
View commentI'm not sure how I felt about this article. It was different, but not really in a good way.
Grace6
The Visiting Child
4/7/2011
View commentI'm not sure how I felt about this article. It was different, but not really in a good way.
Grace6
The Visiting Child
4/7/2011
View commentI don't think that cheapmm is on this site for the right reasons. I hope all his comments get deleted soon. Very annoying. Thank you.
Grace6
Life Among the Pirates
4/7/2011
View commentSuch a unique story. I loved it!
Grace6
Life Among the Pirates
4/7/2011
View commentI agree with Oliver's comment. "Fascinating story, I would be keen to know if there are any tell-tale signs that a book is a pirated version. Do they have ISBN numbers for instance?" I am interested in this too.
Grace6
Life Among the Pirates
4/7/2011
View commentliving in Europe I am glad that Grau Avenue contributed to some extent to allay my thirst for literature and at the same time to increase my curiosity for even more books.
I understand the majority of Peruvians who have to look for other, very "creative" alternatives if they want to take part of world's literature
Grace6
Lost Cat
4/7/2011
View commentThis makes me want to hug my cat a little more today lol!
Grace6
Lost Cat
4/7/2011
View commentAnybebeme... your second to last comment made me laugh out loud!!!
Grace6
Lost Cat
4/7/2011
View commentI felt wonderfully uplifted (and perhaps no longer secretly ashamed) to read about such feelings for creatures small and frail. For many reasons this story has awakened sensitivities to relationships that I felt intuitively but have not fully thought through until now.
Christos Polydorou
All I Know About Gertrude Stein
15/6/2011
View commentStunning writing, as always. Jeanette Winterson is an international treasure.