Subscribe to Granta today

Bad Women, Good Feminists?

|

Ahead of the next instalment of his Shoreditch House LIterary Salon, tonight, Damian Barr wonders which men it is that apparently don’t buy books by women, and whether men can be good feminists too.

Author Geoff Dyer with Damian Barr, at the Shoreditch House Literary Salon (photograph © Daisy Honeybunn)

I was the only man in my women’s studies class – isolated in a one-man gamete ghetto, avoided by my so-called sisters. Treated like a peeping tom in the changing rooms at a convent school, stared at whenever the patriarchy was mentioned as if I personally represented thousands of years of misogyny. I was the oppressive Adam to their emancipated Eve. It was not cool.

Starting an answer with ‘As a feminist...’, I was told I was not a feminist and never could be, because I was a man. I was eventually permitted to call myself a ‘pro-feminist’, and slunk to the back of the class. But this wasn’t feminism. This was man-hating.

A similar thing happened to me aged ten when I abandoned the knot-tying, camping Boy Scouts for the baton-twirling, campy majorettes. I pleaded to be allowed to join their glittery ranks and on that occasion was allowed to march with girls in miniskirts. Finally, I was given pom-poms and knowing looks and told to get on with it. I lacked the coordination and conviction necessary to make it as a majorette in the end, but I was at least given a chance at equality.

I am a feminist. I actively support the rights of all women to equal pay, to reproductive liberty, to love whom and how they choose, to all the freedoms men currently enjoy. And I don’t care who knows it. I’m out and I’m trying to be proud.

I am, apparently, in a minority. Marketing departments continue to claim that men won’t buy books by women (hence George Eliot, JK Rowling and SJ Parris). Judging from my bookshelves, I am not one of them. Of the 542 books crowding my flat, 350 are by women. It took me quite some time to do that bit of counting so I’d like you to appreciate it.

I am a feminist reader; I identify more with women than men. Like most women, I also sleep with men. This, I believe, gives me a useful insight. So I was excited about Granta’s ‘F Word’ issue. The only flaw I can find in 265 pages is the total absence of men. It’s not that men are under-represented: they aren’t represented at all.

Now you see why I staked my feminist credentials up front. Men can be feminists too and surely there’s value in hearing from at least one of us? Otherwise it’s like having peace talks with only one side present.

Surely castrating men from the pages of ‘The F Word’ is counter-productive and a kind of sexism? Can we not be trusted with pom-poms? Must we be banished to the back of class?

I decided we would explore this issue tonight at the next instalment of my Shoreditch House Literary Salon – where I am always careful to balance male and female voices. Rachel Cusk will read from her powerful and intensely personal piece on divorce. In it she tells one side of an all too common story in which ‘feminist’ is almost a dirty word. Would she have invited men to contribute? Or has she heard enough from us? Maggie O’Farrell has described the family as ‘a crucible of stories’ and it is from the family – or rather, families – that her finely wrought stories spring. Women are at the centre of these families and not always beneficently. Can bad women be good feminists? We’ll find out.

Tonight’s event is sold out, but visit the Shoredtich House Literary Salon’s Facebook page for more information, and to be notified about upcoming events.

***

‘Then by flame-light I see: I am burning/ his old easel’: read a new poem by National Book Critics Circle Award-winner Sharon Olds.

Also online: an interview with Urvashi Butalia, in which she talks about her essay on the hijras, communities of transsexuals in India.

Comments (76)

You need to create an account or log in to comment.

  1. alexmen

    Tue Jul 15 07:19:10 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material....

    הסעות בלונדון
    http://www.ycar.co.uk/

    #
  2. MuazaLas

    Tue Jul 29 00:55:46 BST 2014

    step up height increaser is really a amazing solution for a short height person. it gives excellent results.
    http://putperjaka.blogspot.com/2014/07/agen-texas-dan-domino-online-indonesia-terpercaya.html

    #
  3. show12345

    Tue Jul 22 08:14:03 BST 2014

    I worked both for Nick Macpherson, now the Permanent Secretary of the Treasury, and Jeremy Heywood, the new Cabinet Secretary.

    including presentation choices
    http://ireport.cnn.com/docs/DOC-1132595

    #
  4. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Mon Aug 04 12:30:17 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.

    to read more about them
    http://www.thumbtack.com/profile/services/880zElJihi7xPQ/

    #
  5. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Sun Jul 13 10:33:25 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed

    looking up their official page
    https://www.facebook.com/cegtek

    #
  6. show12345

    Thu Jul 17 12:01:59 BST 2014

    I was eventually permitted to call myself a ‘pro-feminist’, and slunk to the back of the class. But this wasn’t feminism. This was man-hating.

    Skor Hari ini
    http://bola.prediksi.org

    #
  7. show12345

    Thu Jul 17 12:02:49 BST 2014

    I was eventually permitted to call myself a ‘pro-feminist’, and slunk to the back of the class. But this wasn’t feminism. This was man-hating.

    Skor Hari ini
    http://bola.prediksi.org

    #
  8. alexmen

    Mon Jul 07 06:37:41 BST 2014

    It is the only way we will reduce health disparities in our communities..

    lol how to play with flamers

    http://boostelo.net/related/lol-boosting-psychology

    #
  9. alexmen

    Mon Aug 11 11:07:12 BST 2014

    This pece of writing will help the internet viewers for setting up new werbsite or even a blog frolm start to end. <a href='http://www.freedompop.com/freedompop-review' target='_blank'>the new privacy phone</a>

    #
  10. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Tue Aug 05 12:38:47 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.

    http://www.grandluxuryhotels.com/hotels/the-grand-collection?world=-DabtwbhoG&amp;gclid=CPGuz_Se974CFYQ-MgodJjoABw
    http://www.grandluxuryhotels.com/hotels/the-grand-collection?world=-DabtwbhoG&amp;gclid=CPGuz_Se974CFYQ-MgodJjoABw

    #
  11. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Wed Jul 09 12:11:02 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users

    DSD Login
    http://dsd.loginq.com/

    #
  12. alexmen

    Sun Jul 27 09:55:49 BST 2014

    e moderated. Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or remo
    mapquest
    http://www.ezdrivingdirections.com

    #
  13. show12345

    Sun Jul 13 08:43:52 BST 2014

    I was a man. I was eventually permitted to call myself a ‘pro-feminist’, and slunk to the back of the class. But this wasn’t feminism. This was man-hating.

    Christian Broda
    http://www.nber.org/authors_papers/christian_broda

    #
  14. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Mon Aug 11 12:27:49 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.

    investigate this site
    http://about.me/theantiquewinecompany

    #
  15. alexmen

    Tue Jul 22 07:26:01 BST 2014

    rated. Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting s
    Free PDF Links
    http://freepdfspp.com/

    #
  16. show12345

    Sat Jul 12 09:36:26 BST 2014

    This, I believe, gives me a useful insight. So I was excited about Granta’s ‘F Word’ issue. The only flaw I can find in 265 pages is the total absence of men. It’s not that men are under-represented: they aren’t represented at all.

    mini servicing
    http://www.car-accident-repair-london.co.uk/

    #
  17. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Sat Jun 28 06:47:35 BST 2014

    Great, these kinds of sites are helpful for searching nice and useful stuff ,

    changing the healthcare industry
    http://about.me/BrianTorchin

    #
  18. show12345

    Mon Aug 04 14:14:17 BST 2014

    This is the best of five different water kettles that I have tried. That was two weeks ago, and it's still running strong on that initial charge after daily use.

    newsvine
    http://rolandhughes.newsvine.com/_news/2014/04/25/23624155-brad-reifler-on-investing-in-commodities-and-forex-markets new

    #
  19. alexmen

    Thu Jul 24 12:14:14 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users

    residential treatment
    http://www.perthamboychamber.com/court-ordering-kids-to-residential-treatment/

    #
  20. show12345

    Tue Jul 15 01:39:18 BST 2014

    Women are at the centre of these families and not always beneficently. Can bad women be good feminists? We’ll find out.

    perth web development
    http://optimiseonline.com.au

    #
  21. alexmen

    Sat Jun 28 07:15:46 BST 2014

    I enjoyed your article; visiting your website was fun and I Learned Few Things from your informative post. Thanks for sharing it.
    http://usalpnprograms.com - Find the Best LPN Schools
    http://usalpnprograms.com

    #
  22. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Thu Aug 07 10:32:58 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users

    WordPress
    http://paulmathieson.wordpress.com/2014/04/14/key-tenets-of-financial-success-from-paul-mathieson/

    #
  23. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Sun Jun 08 12:49:14 BST 2014

    Hello! I simply want to offer you a big thumbs up for the excellent information you have got here on this post. I'll be returning to your web site for more soon.

    Targeted Traffic
    https://www.google.com.pk/search?q=timelytraffic.com&amp;ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a&channel=sb&gws_rd=cr&ei=zBGOU7XEK8a0O8yXgbgJ

    #
  24. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Wed Jul 09 10:24:32 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users

    FarmVille Login
    http://farmville.loginq.com/

    #
  25. MuazaLas

    Thu Jul 24 04:55:16 BST 2014

    Very nice blog and articles. I am realy very happy to visit your blog. Now I am found which I actually want. I check your blog everyday and try to learn something from your blog. Thank you and waiting for your new post.
    http://goo.gl/LSosAK
    http://muaza-las.blogspot.com/

    #
  26. show12345

    Thu Jul 10 12:19:22 BST 2014

    Greetings! Very useful advice in this particular article! It's the little changes that produce the most significant changes. Thanks for sharing!

    things to do in Grenada
    http://www.thingstodoingrenada.com/

    #
  27. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Wed Aug 06 10:40:22 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.

    http://www.bmfbovespa.com.br/pt-br/mercados/download/Vic-Mall-Anuncio-de-inicio.pdf
    http://www.bmfbovespa.com.br/pt-br/mercados/download/Vic-Mall-Anuncio-de-inicio.pdf

    #
  28. alexmen

    Tue Jun 17 10:02:11 BST 2014

    Greetings! Very useful advice in this particular article! It's the little changes that produce the most significant changes. Thanks for sharing!
    one of the ways Paul Mathieson found success
    http://paulmathieson.wordpress.com/2014/04/14/key-tenets-of-financial-success-from-paul-mathieson/

    #
  29. show12345

    Mon Jul 07 07:30:10 BST 2014

    I actively support the rights of all women to equal pay, to reproductive liberty, to love whom and how they choose, to all the freedoms men currently enjoy. And I don’t care who knows it. I’m out and I’m trying to be proud.

    sometimes helping the up and coming realtors
    http://ireport.cnn.com/docs/DOC-1126339

    #
  30. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Sun Jun 15 15:13:55 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.

    Igor Cornelsen
    http://www.bubblews.com/news/3031278-the-best-stock-strategies-straight-from-the-mouth-of-igor-cornelsen

    #
  31. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Mon Jun 16 12:09:33 BST 2014

    memories are very encouraging, especially for those who also have shared memories of it.

    for more on Marc Sparks
    http://www.crunchbase.com/person/marc-sparks

    #
  32. alexmen

    Thu Jul 10 08:21:24 BST 2014

    I am not hopeful this will ever happen without MSM support. But we all know the MSM is part of the system and shills for a certain *****y little country.
    rhinoplasty md
    http://atlantarhinoplastycritic.puzl.com/

    #
  33. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Thu Jun 19 09:13:47 BST 2014

    especially for those who also have shared memories of it......

    iphone 5 screen protector clear

    http://www.amazon.com/Window-Armor-iPhone-5s-Protector/dp/B00HENW0V8

    #
  34. show12345

    Thu Jun 19 13:21:42 BST 2014

    Treated like a peeping tom in the changing rooms at a convent school, stared at whenever the patriarchy was mentioned as if I personally represented thousands of years of misogyny. I was the oppressive Adam to their emancipated Eve. It was not cool.
    Herbal Breast Enhancement
    http://www.maxbust36.com

    #
  35. alexmen

    Fri Jun 20 05:40:43 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.
    even more information
    https://www.facebook.com/ben.shaoul

    #
  36. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Fri Jun 20 19:03:25 BST 2014

    I have found some really interesting information about this topic through this article.

    Susan P McGalla Salary Bonus Stock Options for Wet Seal Inc. - Salary.com
    http://www1.salary.com/Susan-P-McGalla-Salary-Bonus-Stock-Options-for-WET-SEAL-INC.html

    #
  37. show12345

    Sat Jun 21 12:53:01 BST 2014

    Marketing departments continue to claim that men won’t buy books by women (hence George Eliot, JK Rowling and SJ Parris). Judging from my bookshelves, I am not one of them. Of the 542 books crowding my flat, 350 are by women. It took me quite some time to do that bit of counting so I’d like you to appreciate it.

    forex
    http://grentone.com/

    #
  38. show12345

    Sun Jun 22 08:30:11 BST 2014

    The only flaw I can find in 265 pages is the total absence of men. It’s not that men are under-represented: they aren’t represented at all.

    instant racing
    http://article.wn.com/view/2014/02/21/Ky_lawmakers_responding_to_Instant_Racing_ruling/

    #
  39. alexmen

    Sun Jun 22 20:36:56 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.
    Chase Auto Finance Login
    http://chaseautofinance.loginq.com/

    #
  40. show12345

    Wed Jun 25 09:00:06 BST 2014

    Maggie O’Farrell has described the family as ‘a crucible of stories’ and it is from the family – or rather, families – that her finely wrought stories spring. Women are at the centre of these families and not always beneficently. Can bad women be good feminists? We’ll find out.

    the new privacy phone
    http://www.freedompop.com/freedompop-review|

    #
  41. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Wed Jun 25 13:16:31 BST 2014

    The clarity on your submit is simply nice and i could suppose you're a professional

    Marnie Bennett
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMeDdTeFDNE

    #
  42. show12345

    Thu Jun 26 15:05:04 BST 2014

    I actively support the rights of all women to equal pay, to reproductive liberty, to love whom and how they choose, to all the freedoms men currently enjoy. And I don’t care who knows it. I’m out and I’m trying to be proud.

    Meredith Nelson
    http://310bocai.com

    #
  43. show12345

    Sun Jun 29 06:52:54 BST 2014

    This, I believe, gives me a useful insight. So I was excited about Granta’s ‘F Word’ issue. The only flaw I can find in 265 pages is the total absence of men. It’s not that men are under-represented: they aren’t represented at all.

    click here
    http://firstcnaclasses.com

    #
  44. alexmen

    Sun Jun 29 08:07:08 BST 2014

    Keep up the wonderful work, I read few articles on this internet site and I conceive that your weblog is really interesting and holds sets of good information.
    http://creare-magazinonline.blogspot.ro/

    #
  45. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Sun Jun 29 19:19:07 BST 2014

    great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information

    more
    http://bestxraytechnicianschools.com

    #
  46. show12345

    Wed Jul 23 08:37:34 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.

    selling several homes
    http://www.pinterest.com/marniebennett1/

    #
  47. show12345

    Sun Jul 06 08:21:50 BST 2014

    I was given pom-poms and knowing looks and told to get on with it. I lacked the coordination and conviction necessary to make it as a majorette in the end, but I was at least given a chance at equality.

    21 Day Fix
    http://loseweightworkout.org/

    #
  48. jhonmarshal

    Sat Jul 05 10:25:36 BST 2014

    comearredareunbagno.it

    If I would have to choose one website to visit every single day it would be definitely this one. It has everything I need. It feels like all posts are written specially for me! Thanks for that. http://comearredareunbagno.it

    #
  49. jhonmarshal

    Sat Jul 05 08:20:10 BST 2014

    http://bagnidesign.it

    All comments are moderated. Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material. http://bagnidesign.it

    #
  50. show12345

    Sat Jul 05 06:48:21 BST 2014

    providing instant cloud connectivity to devices and making it easier to develop applications using remote connected devices, remotely update firmware, and troubleshoot problems during development.

    social media guru
    http://www.toptensocialmedia.com/social-media-business/top-ten-social-media-sites-for-business-networking/

    #
  51. show12345

    Sat Jul 05 03:57:28 BST 2014

    You have a responsibility to assist, heal and advocate for all your patients. It is the only way we will reduce health disparities in our communities.

    social media software
    http://www.toptensocialmedia.com/social-media-how-to/10-secrets-to-generating-social-media-leads-online-2/

    #
  52. show12345

    Tue Jul 01 08:10:39 BST 2014

    Treated like a peeping tom in the changing rooms at a convent school, stared at whenever the patriarchy was mentioned as if I personally represented thousands of years of misogyny. I was the oppressive Adam to their emancipated Eve. It was not cool.

    check it out
    http://allphlebotomytraining.org/

    #
  53. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Tue Jul 01 08:45:45 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users

    American Airlines Login
    http://americanairlines.loginq.com/

    #
  54. show12345

    Wed Jul 02 06:17:12 BST 2014

    Treated like a peeping tom in the changing rooms at a convent school, stared at whenever the patriarchy was mentioned as if I personally represented thousands of years of misogyny. I was the oppressive Adam to their emancipated Eve. It was not cool.

    Nelson Bailey
    http://ardenteflamme.info

    #
  55. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Wed Jul 02 07:12:01 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users

    Christine Alvarado
    http://gatewaytogiving.org

    #
  56. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Sun Aug 10 11:14:39 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.

    http://mashable.com/people/igorcornelsen/
    http://mashable.com/people/igorcornelsen/

    #
  57. alexmen

    Sun Aug 10 08:14:40 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material. <a href='http://www.youtube.com/user/salhokair' >http://www.youtube.com/user/salhokair</a>

    #
  58. show12345

    Thu Jul 03 05:44:53 BST 2014

    You have a responsibility to assist, heal and advocate for all your patients. It is the only way we will reduce health disparities in our communities. We also have a responsibility to care for each other as minority nurses.
    West Hampstead Loft
    http://www.theloftking.co.uk/

    #
  59. alexmen

    Wed Aug 13 12:35:50 BST 2014

    We also know that the Taliban made numerous concessions regarding Osama bin Laden to the Bush White House to no avail. It seems clear that the real reason for this war is resource exclusivity. <a href='http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052748703493504576007852312450920' target='_blank'>one of these facts</a>

    #
  60. alexmen

    Wed Aug 13 14:21:39 BST 2014

    We also know that the Taliban made numerous concessions regarding Osama bin Laden to the Bush White House to no avail. It seems clear that the real reason for this war is resource exclusivity. <a href='http://www.crunchbase.com/person/christopher-cowdray' >for more about Christopher</a>

    #
  61. show12345

    Thu Aug 14 22:03:34 BST 2014

    would ever embrace the deep changes that make possible Finland's success. But, a single state could embrace some of the Finnish components. One of those is teacher education.

    https://www.rebelmouse.com/onlinealluremichaelfiore/

    #
  62. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Wed Aug 20 11:38:59 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited....

    Torchin's article on bubblews
    http://www.bubblews.com/news/2931304-preparing-for-a-life-in-the-medical-industry-with-tips-from-brian-torchin

    #
  63. aarij

    Wed Aug 20 14:43:25 BST 2014

    I was eventually permitted to call myself a ‘pro-feminist’, and slunk to the back of the class. <a href='http://www.jamiestaff.com/' title='Jamie Staff' target='_blank'>Jamie Staff</a>

    #