Discussion
One of the aims of Granta.com is to encourage discussion and debate. As such, we welcome your comments on the pieces we publish on this site.
In order to enjoy the full benefits of Granta.com, including its comment facilities, you will need to create a Granta account. You can do so by clicking here.
All comments are moderated. Offensive or abusive comments will be deleted as will unrelated, self-promotional or commerical links or spam. We reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.


There were 545 comments found.
Showing page 1 of 22
halim
Harold
9/1/2012
View comment
Based on the fact that most people who write don't even take there time to organize their post. I take out few seconds or minutes to say a big thank you whenever I go through a good post. Nice work.
http://repliquemontresprix.com
halim
Teardrop
9/1/2012
View comment
This must have really taken hard work to put together. Nice post and thanks for posting.
http://montre-montres.net
halim
Interview: Justin Torres
9/1/2012
View comment
Great post from a great mind. Thanks for sharing.
http://sacs-deluxe.com
saadrooking201
The Dog of Ṭeṭvāl
8/1/2012
View comment
Most people in the United States don’t realize how rugged the land is in Idaho. These maps provided here at Nat GEO Maps make it easier to plan trips into the back country of just about any state.
http://www.placestovisitinnewyork.net
Top 5 places to visit in new york
saadrooking201
Working Lives (2)
8/1/2012
View comment
Most people in the United States don’t realize how rugged the land is in Idaho. These maps provided here at Nat GEO Maps make it easier to plan trips into the back country of just about any state.
http://www.placestovisitinnewyork.net
Top 5 places to visit in new york
saadrooking201
The Trouble with the Horses
8/1/2012
View comment
I just finished "sister's brother" and it was a great read, with some of the best cover art I've seen in years.
Top Places to visit in new york
http://www.placestovisitinnewyork.net
saadrooking201
Sayed Bilal
8/1/2012
View comment
Nothing is left for the parents but tears and prayer. The police order them to bury their son that same night, to avoid a disturbance on Friday, the holiest day of the Muslim week. The parents try to negotiate, but it’s no use: unless they drop their demands, Ibrahim will not be released. The parents know the officers will not hesitate to kill him. Sayed Bilal is finally buried just before midnight.
Places to visit in new york
http://www.placestovisitinnewyork.net
halim
Interview: Owen Freeman
8/1/2012
View comment
The time spent here, is really a time well spent. Nice post. Keep it coming.
http://sac-sacs.com
halim
Menu: Extinction
8/1/2012
View comment
You are doing a great work here by putting up these great posts. Keep them coming.
http://montremontres.com
halim
Interview: Peter Orner
8/1/2012
View comment
I wish all postings were this good. Nice post.
http://repliquemontresprix.com
henk
The Plano Suicides
8/1/2012
View comment
Übersetzung Finnisch Deutsch http://www.profi-fachuebersetzungen.de http://www.profischnell.com Übersetzung Englisch Deutsch, Übersetzung Deutsch englisch www.uebersetzung-deutsch-englisch.com / http://www.profi-fachuebersetzung.de
halim
The Plano Suicides
7/1/2012
View comment
A well drafted post. Thanks for posting. Hoping to see more. http://repliquemontresprix.com
halim
At The Kitchen Table
7/1/2012
View comment
I love the way you write your post, it is well organised. Keep it coming and thanks for posting. http://sacssacs.com/
halim
Dark Night
7/1/2012
View comment
This is commendable. I will like to see more of this well constructed post. Thanks for sharing. http://repliquemontresprix.com
halim
Interview: Karen Russell
7/1/2012
View comment
This post is awesome. This is one of the best posts I have seen in recent times. Keep it coming. <a href="http://repliquemontresprix.com">Réplique Montres</a>
Sinibaldi
If God Existed, He’d Be A Solid Midfielder
6/1/2012
View comment
In the flower.
In this way,
and with a
delicate song,
there's a flower
where a fine
day appears
in the novel
seaside.
Francesco Sinibaldi
distortedLens
The Madonna of the Sea
5/1/2012
View comment
Immigration is the great unifier of man and womankind: before letters, phone calls, social media. It is hard to read this and not place oneself within the greater context of our social, political and human realities. I can't help but wonder if we need to reshift our focus from freedom, self-determination, and materialism to something more humane. Perhaps if we can all agree upon a definition of what a human is and what a human is not, travesties such as these can be averted. Bravo to you, Ms. Mengiste. You have given us a tale we can apply to any context in the world, to that member of our family who has risked everything for something more, for their right to be human. I think what many of us forget, the billions of us, is that this is a universal construct. We are all complicit, but we are also all in possession of real power that can make a difference. I hope this story, essay, moment in our collective history, is shared with all of those who refuse to see the power they have to make real changes in this world.
lampgh
Detroit, 1966
31/0/2012
View comment
I loved this article! It perfectly captured the way we wiled away the days in my neighborhood too.
spencejam
Detroit, 1966
31/0/2012
View comment
This was my Detroit, too, though I was born in '68: worldly and provincial, hot & sticky, Black and White and Jewish and ill-at-ease with itself.
I've often thought that Detroit's history as a city forecast a lot of what came to pass all over the US economically and socially in the 70s. It's enlightening to receive glimpses of that bigger picture, through the lens of a memoir; it's a living snapshot from a place that has a lot to say. Waiting for more...!
Website Design
Cinema's Invisible Art
31/0/2012
View comment
It is always said one picture encompasses lots of word and cinema is itself a series of pictures. I read your post,it is superb.
KC
Detroit, 1966
30/0/2012
View comment
What a delightful story! When will the next installation of your childhood saga be published? I want to know how the growing tension between the parents develops (does it get resolved or spin out of control?) and how the dynamic between the siblings changes with the arrival of a fourth sister. Bravo Ms. Schuster!
CG
Detroit, 1966
30/0/2012
View comment
I'm not from Detroit, but I was 10 in 1966 and I love what Lynda Schuster does to make me happy and melancholy all at once.
cnheckt
The Moon and Back
28/0/2012
View comment
wonderful piece - flows so well, feels so natural. great writing.
tiffanyann
The Moon and Back
27/0/2012
View comment
Beautifully written. I'd love to read more of Jessica Thummel's stories on upcoming issues of Granta!
Reader
Detroit, 1966
26/0/2012
View comment
Excellent article! I can almost feel the oppressive Michigan heat as the writer describes her ride in the hot car. Ms Schuster's writing evokes a time and place since forgotten, where little girls can still dream about far away places not yet visited, rather than search them on Google. Wonderful!