Discussion
One of the aims of Granta.com is to encourage discussion and debate. As such, we welcome your comments on the pieces we publish on this site.
In order to enjoy the full benefits of Granta.com, including its comment facilities, you will need to create a Granta account. You can do so by clicking here.
All comments are moderated. Offensive or abusive comments will be deleted as will unrelated, self-promotional or commerical links or spam. We reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.


There were 1542 comments found.
Showing page 36 of 62
Letícia Castro
Brazil: A User’s Guide
6/10/2012
View comment
Like a true Brazilian, everything I have to say is: Then it is ok!
Excellent post! And yes, that's nothing but reality.But you forgot to mention that we we are serial kissers, kissing everybody hello and goodbye. So, beijinhos! =)
Letícia Castro
Brazil: A User’s Guide
6/10/2012
View comment
Like a true Brazilian, everything I have to say is: Then it is ok!
Excellent post! And yes, that's nothing but reality.But you forgot to mention that we we are serial kissers, kissing everybody hello and goodbye. So, beijinhos! =)
Andy Tepper
Six Brazilian Songs
31/9/2012
View comment
Really enjoyed this piece--beautiful music, wonderfully captured. Two of my favorite Brazilian musicians as well: Marisa Monte and Maria Bethania!
SteveK
At War With Writing About War
29/9/2012
View comment
"...history suggests that Hemingway copped his style from the writers who came up in The Pulps: James M. Cain, Dashiell Hammett, Raymond Chandler, and my personal favorite, Jim Thompson."
Two minutes of Googling suggests that Cain didn't publish his first novel until 1934, after Hemingway was already a literary heavyweight. Both Chandler and Thompson got going even later, in the '40s.
Who's factchecking?
Sinibaldi
Interview: A.M. Homes
29/9/2012
View comment
Dans le sourire.
Dans le
sourire d'une
fleur je vois
l'éternité, le
son de la
neige et encore
l'harmonie qui
chante le
matin....
Francesco Sinibaldi
kcoon
The Island of Hawkers
25/9/2012
View comment
nice description of Penang Hawker Foods :) i'm a Penangnite and now still residing in Penang, reading this still make my mouth watery and stomach feel hungry ahaha.
By the way, using the ferry is one of the popular way of coming into the island, but coming in via the Penang Bridge is also a spectacular view of the island :). After all it's the longest bridge in Malaysia... which only currently passed by the 2nd Penang Bridge which is currently under construction
Sinibaldi
Dispatches from Ambassador to Brazil, Earth
22/9/2012
View comment
Sweetness.
In the sound
of a shadow
full of happiness,
near a lonesome
desire calling
the present
and a delicate
thought.
Francesco Sinibaldi
sbm64
Granta Audio: Alison Moore
22/9/2012
View comment
Witeathome
Do you see an orange arrow to click on??
If not, the audio is also posted on the website Soundcloud (a fabulous free website with music etc. ) the podcast is called====
Ted Hodgkinson Granta
The Granta Podcast Episode 47
I hope this helps!
witeathome
Granta Audio: Alison Moore
18/9/2012
View comment
I would really like to know how to listen to this. There are no instructions, and no way I can see to start it.
witeathome
The Island of Hawkers
17/9/2012
View comment
An extraordinary rich description that catches all the senses, and the heart. The shouts and cries of the market, the smell and colours of the food, the hiss as it fries, the skill.
And drumming into the mind, an omen. The advancing age of these people, the inevitable loss of skill and livelihood, cuisine and accord.
As a way of life is marvellous captured in words before it dies, we sense with sadness, that huge global chain with massive logo and insatiable appetite, lurks hungry in the wings. Having already devoured the young of these people, it is ready to carve up and greedily swallow the carcass of the whole culture depicted here.
But at least, thanks to this writer, we have secured these words.
Espumoso
The Island of Hawkers
16/9/2012
View comment
Made me want to rush out and order a blanquette de veau with a croute au fromage to begin.
SILENT_B_
Auto-Suggestion
14/9/2012
View comment
Barthes / A Lover's Discourse / Dark Glasses
gebinsk
Grand Mal
10/9/2012
View comment
Patrick, that was a haunting story, if only because of how closely it mirrors my experience. I was diagnosed with Juvenile Myoclonic Epilepsy at age 18 after two grand mal seizures. At the time I was a student pilot with 40 hours under my belt--my career path, as you can imagine, has since changed.
Because you mentioned having auras I wanted to suggest a trick I discovered early on that gives me some peace-of-mind. I typically know at least an hour beforehand that I'm going to have a seizure, so I asked my first neurologist if there was a medication I could take at that moment to prevent it from happening, and she prescribed me a few doses of lorazepam (but many similar medications would work.) Now I carry them with me on my keychain and have a few stashed around the house, just in case. As I asked my doctor, if I know a seizure is coming, how is my condition served by allowing it to happen and losing my ability to drive for half a year?
Which brings me to the second discovery I made, also early in my treatment: most neurologists have all the bedside manners of a spider.
Best of luck to you,
Adam
makul65
Interview: Salman Rushdie
6/9/2012
View comment
I find it ironical that the person who issued the fatwa sentencing Salman Rushdie to death,passed away not long after issuing the fatwa.
Gaurav Deka
Radio Story
6/9/2012
View comment
Absolutely brilliant and sublime Anushka. You have narrated it in such a simple way yet with a thudering impact. You deserve it by all means. I read it thrice!
Sinibaldi
Interview: Nicola Barker
2/9/2012
View comment
Persuasiva rima.
Así, en el
canto de una
mágica rima,
en el sol
que regresa
como el nuevo
pájaro en un
llanto perpetuo....
Francesco Sinibaldi
Andrew Goldspink
Meeting the psychiatrist’s wife
29/8/2012
View comment
Beautiful piece of work.
Ondeemas
Frissure
24/8/2012
View comment
Brigid Collin's magnificent input into this powerful and moving collaboration is not done justice by the design of this on-line publication.
Please, please enlarge the illustrations that inspired this writing to a comprehendible size that can be appreciated alongside the writing, or add an option to enlarge?
Sinibaldi
Granta Audio: Lawrence Joseph
24/8/2012
View comment
Le chemin des poésies.
Une rime
éphémère quand
le chant du
matin dessine
le sourire
des chansons
désolées.
Francesco Sinibaldi
Hettie Ashwin
Accident
24/8/2012
View comment
I am a great fan of the monologue style and this one is a cracker. The break in the middle when we are told he is not sure if he shouted or he doesn't recall anymore is well placed.
A slice of life at its most hectic and I feel for the guy.
witeathome
The Doctor Will See You Now
21/8/2012
View comment
I know this may be efficient, but I find it eerie and scary. A kind of complete study in alienation - all the individuals do not relate at all - 'ships passing in the night' would make a good title!
The sad thing is that this would seem to suggest that touch, talking, and personal support do not necessarily lead to the best results in these circumstances - that machinery and distance are more reliable and thorough!
I wonder - what about the holistic effects of trust, personal attention, and reassurance, on healing and survival?
Sinibaldi
The Burning of the Rocks
17/8/2012
View comment
The glad sun.
With a
certain delight
a magical
sound returns
in the place
where your
memory
outshines....
Francesco Sinibaldi
Henrietta
Homecoming - II
17/8/2012
View comment
This comment has been removed by the moderators.
Aikay
People Don’t Get Depressed in Nigeria
11/8/2012
View comment
This is fine piece of writing: fluid, pliant and hauntingly tender. But it does not qualify to be described as an essay. It is rather memoir-like in nature. An essay usually expresses some personal opinion (of the essayist) on its subject-matter. I can't see that this piece does. Perhaps it marks a shift from the traditional form of the essay as we know it.
mystique
People Don’t Get Depressed in Nigeria
8/8/2012
View comment
I love this piece. It absolutely captures the essence of the people without stereotyping them as is our wont in Nigeria.
It also points out the need for greater emphasis/advocay on mental health issues in Nigeria.
If Medical professionals hold such beliefs as your young "corper" doctor,what is the average Nigerians view on depression?