Discussion
One of the aims of Granta.com is to encourage discussion and debate. As such, we welcome your comments on the pieces we publish on this site.
In order to enjoy the full benefits of Granta.com, including its comment facilities, you will need to create a Granta account. You can do so by clicking here.
All comments are moderated. Offensive or abusive comments will be deleted as will unrelated, self-promotional or commerical links or spam. We reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.


There were 1536 comments found.
Showing page 61 of 62
Bookworm
Where I’m Calling From
15/6/2009
View comment
A wonderful evocative piece.
One small nitpick -- Auburn, New York is to the west of Utica, not the north.
saju
Fly Away Home
13/6/2009
View comment
nice account...
jeelani
New Voices
10/6/2009
View comment
She is Jessica. I am Jeelani. She wrote that. I write this.
She said heart. I listen life.
She drank tears.I cried blood.
What a savage world. What a lethal time. Again I read this line. I knew what you meant.
JPS
Celebrating Granta 107
9/6/2009
View comment
I have got my copy already and I though the essay by Mary Gaitskill was inspiring...Also, Will Self's eulogy on JG Ballard was worth the subscription price in itself - (well almost!)
Valverde
New Voices
6/6/2009
View comment
Made an account just to post this.
Wow. My stomach has dropped out.
Annie Paul
Growing up with the King of Pop
3/6/2009
View comment
Wondered when you were going to say something bout MJ. love this line:
Michael Jackson lost his childhood but he extended mine.
he was the coolest wasn't he?
Yours Truly
New Voices
1/6/2009
View comment
Wonderful transition: We left the door unlocked. You found a lump. This reads like a poem.
LynnScarapella
New Voices
1/6/2009
View comment
What a breathtaking piece! I haven't been moved like this by a story in a very long time. I could just read it again and again and again. And I will!
Congratulations, Jessica!
Cristian
New Voices
28/5/2009
View comment
What a story!
I like to read new voices, writers that are not being forced to write a story. Profesional writers are writung -sometime- too much, they should pause, do something else, recharge the batteries to see if they can write again with this fresh english, direct, to the point. CONGRATULATIONS!
Victoria Mixon
New Voices
27/5/2009
View comment
I couldn't stick with just the beauty of the exposition. I also discussed the meticulous use of first and second person, for the benefit of every writer who's ever wondered, "How is it done right?"
This is how it's done Right.
Victoria
http://victoriamixon.com
David Gleeson
New Voices
26/5/2009
View comment
The drift is established almost from the outset, making its ending all but inevitable: death or break-up. But that doesn't detract from a wonderful progression carried by a unique style of prose.
zacharypace
New Voices
26/5/2009
View comment
stunning
Aliss929
New Voices
26/5/2009
View comment
Just lovely. Vanagan made me giggle.
Victoria Mixon
New Voices
25/5/2009
View comment
This is beautiful. What a haunting combination of telling detail and simple understatement. I'll be linking to it from my post on 6/26/09 as an example of exquisite exposition.
Victoria
http://victoriamixon.com
southcoastsounds
An interview with John Freeman
25/5/2009
View comment
Welcome to an inspiring new job. What a challenge you have!
I agree with asking people in The Middle East, Asia and Africa to tell their stories, but please don't forget Europeans - particularly the ex-Soviet states.
Can I suggest you commission something from Polish writer Pawel Huelle? - his work has impressed me greatly over the last couple of years
southcoastsounds
New Voices
25/5/2009
View comment
A fine piece of writing. The story of so many lives, but unique to this one. Everything changes when the things we take for granted are no longer there. Excellent
southcoastsounds
A question of identity
25/5/2009
View comment
Hair dressing is one of the few services which cannot be automated. Every hairdresser is (should be?) an artist in their own right. It is an interesting concept to write about all the hairdressers you have known. For me however they all blur into a long series of conversations about holiday and what I am doing the next weekend. For the last few years my wife has cut my hair with Wahl clippers. I get the best haircuts I have ever had now!
Anosh Malekar
An interview with John Freeman
17/5/2009
View comment
Great to have you here Mr Freeman. And hope to see a bolder, and a bit less respectable Granta, as you have said in the interview. I agree with you that this is not a magazine, really, but a cultural space where anything can happen. Best Wishes!
Judy K
An interview with John Freeman
10/5/2009
View comment
I've been following your career, Mr Freeman, In a lurking sort of manner. I am an admirer of your energy, initiative and many of your reviews. Congratulations on your new post in the lit world. I think your ideas are intelligent and "grand" in the British meaning. Best wishes.
Bill_Ectric
Portrait of my Father
5/5/2009
View comment
... and Ray Liotta as Dad.
jempud
Keeping it in the family
4/5/2009
View comment
This was a good read - well written, and moving without being schmaltzy. And how do we know if our memories are really ours, or just the cumulative effect of remembering ourselves or others talking about things?
Although your father's age I never met him, but he comes across (in the same video clips you've seen) as an immensely likable guy. I'm sorry for him (and your family) that he was embroiled in such unsavory events. I'm pleased that he pulled away in the end.
Crockett is another guy I would have liked to meet - sufficiently focussed to work things out for himself, without being sucked into the maelstrom of all things Manson.
Anyway, you don't know me (I'm from Patagonia - not unlike Death Valley in some ways), but I just wanted to say that i liked this post. And I had a few minutes time on my hands - an unusual occurrence! My apologies if my comments are inappropriate.
Jem
Peter sparks
Letter from Gaza
3/5/2009
View comment
Cease Fire
19 January 2009
The tank commander, aiming well,
‘took out’ a ‘hostile’ ground floor flat,
and all I loved precipit fell
in pulverised procession. Heart
pierced by rusty concrete bars,
child-choking through a jagged cleft,
fire waxing in my waning stars,
then silence – now a life, bereft,
has but its own curtailèd span:
I watch my sanguinary flow
through mind detached, apart with them
and screaming at our fate, and how
dogmatic faith can love condemn.
Through eddies of consoling dust,
Aeolus wafts a polaroid
(three little grins, entire in trust),
Out of my reach – until the void.
21 January 2009
I’ll take your coat. Ehud will fix a drink.
How was the flight? Few noticed that you’d slipped away?
The Washington distraction must have helped.
So good of you to come and help us celebrate
Completion of our necessary task to fight
And crush this evil force. We did appreciate
Your quiet support, as well as generous supplies
From BAE. Do please sit here and Tzipi, pass
The red to Gordon. I’m afraid the view just now
Is rather badly marred by all the smoke but, as you
English say, an omelette’s only made by breaking eggs.
Another joke: this dish, our delicate cuisine,
Is cooked on phosphorous – so have some more.
There’s plenty where that comes from – it’s from you.
How are the children? Yours I mean of course…
Oh! must you leave so early? We had hoped
You’d stay and see the fireworks soon re-start.
No, we quite understand. We know you can’t stay long
And must stay silent for your public with an even-
handed air of gravitas. Our thanks, and come again.
Kit Stolz
Rhyme and Reason
26/4/2009
View comment
A wonderfully brisk, thoughtful interview...and Pollit's poetry deserves the attention. Is there any other essayist so open-minded in verse?
Rama Lekshman
Video: Ablutions
26/4/2009
View comment
Mother wit! Impressive.
karmen
Portrait of my father
15/4/2009
View comment
I enjoyed reading this post and would enjoy reading more.