Subscribe to Granta today

Elizabeth Bishop and Sacrificial Feminism

|

Photo by J.L. Castel, 1954, Images courtesy of Vassar Archives and Special Collections, Vassar College Library, New York.

As a young poet, Elizabeth Bishop refused to be published in what would be an otherwise all-male anthology; she didn’t want to act as the book’s ‘sex-appeal’. This aversion to the separation of the sexes – which some see as premature frumpiness, others as sacrificial feminism – was something Bishop held dear throughout her poetic career. Her additional stipulation not to be included in all-female poetry anthologies is still adhered to today.

Lumping together artistic work according to gender was, in Bishop’s opinion, detrimental to women’s writing. In a letter to Jean Keefe, she writes: ‘undoubtedly gender does play an important role in the making of any art, but art is art, and to separate writings, paintings, musical compositions, etc., into two sexes is to emphasize values in them that are not art.’

And in a famous Paris Review interview, in which she was called on to defend her position, she stated: ‘I’ve always considered myself a strong feminist. Recently I was interviewed by a reporter from the Chicago Tribune. After I talked to the girl for a few minutes, I realized that she wanted to play me off as an ‘old fashioned’ against Erica Jong, and Adrienne (Rich) whom I like, and other violently feminist people. Which isn’t true at all.’

The ideas that surround Elizabeth Bishop’s poetry should be far from cloudy. Every single word of her limited poetic output has been dissected, disassembled and edited. ‘to separate writings, paintings, musical compositions, etc., into two sexes is to emphasize values in them that are not art.’ Yet her belief that writer could stand on its own as a title, with little need for the preface of lesbian, alcoholic, manic depressive, orphaned or woman is unquestioned, even though these character traits are often pinned to Bishop and credited with having affected her output, with little consideration to her reticence to talk about her personal life. Critics still see the poet inside the poem, pressing the characters of the orphaned daughter with the absent mother and the lesbian alcoholic onto Bishop’s restrained, modest and graceful poems.

This often leads to the conclusion that Bishop was not a particularly ‘feminine’ poet. Indeed, there is evidence of her writing poorly on sex and the self – two traits commonly associated with women’s writing – and preferring to keep her poetry objective, often genderless. Her most prominent poem on gender, ‘In The Waiting Room’, recognizes the subject only to reject it. After seeing some quite horrifying breasts, she suggests ‘Why should I be my aunt,/ or me, or anyone?’, while her famous love poem, ‘Shampoo’, is intimate but genderless, the lover in question a ‘friend,/ precipitate and pragmatical.’

So was it her belief that ‘female poets’ were automatically turned into ‘others’, outside of the canon? Or was it that she associated femininity with sentimentality, openness: things she strove to avoid in public spaces? Whichever is true, her definition as a poet surely rises above any labels.

And what of all-female anthologies? There is an ongoing debate about prefacing a writer with his or her gender, and it is, irrefutably, a one-sided practice. Yet growing up with The Bloodaxe Modern Women Poets anthology, edited by Deryn Rees-Jones didn’t do me any harm (except for Bishop’s omission), and served only as encouragement. These anthologies attempt to emphasize the prominence of poets who, because of their gender, were secondary in the past. All-female collections give these writers an opportunity to be read on their own terms, and with their own prerogative. ■

~

Also on The F Word Online:

‘The Old Fuel’: A new poem by Emily Berry, and an interview with her, here.

‘Your world doesn’t exist anymore’: Four women and one revolution in Cairo’s Tahrir Square, January 2011.

You’re a what kind of feminist? A Treatise on Political Philosophy at the Apex of American Empire, or a new poem by Megan Levad.

~
Subscribe to Granta magazine today.
Granta 115: The F Word

Comments (41)

You need to create an account or log in to comment.

  1. alexmen

    Wed Jul 09 11:26:42 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.
    atlanta doctors
    http://www.stockvault.net/user/profile/122108

    #
  2. alikhan_095

    Fri May 30 23:37:05 BST 2014

    Really nice and interesting post. I was looking for this kind of information and enjoyed reading this one. Keep posting. Thanks for sharing.

    SEC
    http://sportsfan1984.com/sec-store/alabama-crimson-tide/

    #
  3. SHY

    Thu May 29 09:16:45 BST 2014

    Thank you for sharing this wonderful article! I have never seen anything like that before so I really appreciate that. I hope to see more great articles here in the future too so keep it up and good luck to all of you!

    <a href="http://www.10thresults2014.in/2014/05/up-board-10th-class-results-declared.html">up 10th class results 2014</a>
    <a href="http://www.10thresults2014.in/"> uttar pradesh 10th results 2014</a>
    <a href="http://www.10thresults2014.in/2014/05/up-board-10th-class-results-declared.html" >up board 10th result 2014</a>
    <a href="http://www.10thresults2014.in/" >up board 10th results 2014</a>
    <a href="http://www.10thresults2014.in/">up 10th results 2014</a>

    #
  4. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Sat Jul 12 11:37:16 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users

    https://twitter.com/drbenshaoul
    https://twitter.com/drbenshaoul

    #
  5. alexmen

    Thu Jun 19 07:04:30 BST 2014

    The power of women is truly a remarkable force in moving health trends forward to a better place. From vaccination to non communicable chronic disease the strength of womens' influence works wonders in developing countries.
    another in the East Village
    https://www.facebook.com/ben.shaoul

    #
  6. show12345

    Mon Jul 07 10:37:09 BST 2014

    Her most prominent poem on gender, ‘In The Waiting Room’, recognizes the subject only to reject it. After seeing some quite horrifying breasts, she suggests ‘Why should I be my aunt,/ or me, or anyone?’, while her famous love poem, ‘Shampoo’, is intimate but genderless, the lover in question a ‘friend,/ precipitate and pragmatical.’

    from the person herself
    http://new.spring.me/#!/user/MarnieBennett3/timeline/responses

    #
  7. mathiasQuin

    Tue Jul 15 04:21:15 BST 2014

    You could certainly see http://howtoget-yourexback.net/ your expertise within the http://food-addiction.net/ work you write. The world hopes for http://howtopleaseaman.org/ even more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to say how they believe. All the time http://whatisbulimia.org/ follow your http://bingeeating-disorder.net/ heart.

    #
  8. show12345

    Tue Jul 22 10:30:12 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material.

    http://www.findthebest.com/profile/443119/MarcSparks

    #
  9. alexmen

    Tue Jun 17 10:16:27 BST 2014

    Pleasant information, essential and exceptional design, since write about nutrients combined with guidelines and strategies.
    getting a major degree|from his blog post
    http://paulmathiesonn.tumblr.com/

    #
  10. alexmen

    Mon Jul 21 08:02:53 BST 2014

    ts are moderated. Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or re
    Download Free PDF Files
    http://ebooksdirff.com/

    #
  11. JOHN817726

    Sun Jul 20 21:38:58 BST 2014

    I thought it was going to be some boring old post, but it really compensated for my time. I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will locate that extremely useful...
    http://www.liputan6.com

    #
  12. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Thu Jun 19 11:31:15 BST 2014

    I think they didn’t want to wait. When they adopted me my mom was in her late twenties and my dad in his early thirties..... site please visit....

    iphone clear screen protector

    http://www.amazon.com/Window-Armor-iPhone-5s-Protector/dp/B00HENW0V8

    #
  13. alexmen

    Sun Jun 22 09:29:05 BST 2014

    Wonderful!Sincerely interest in your post,will come back soon Crazy with your article,your article is really Great!!!
    Beyblade Battles Login
    http://beybladebattles.loginq.com/

    #
  14. davidjames

    Fri Jun 27 11:29:55 BST 2014

    it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information.
    Lucille Dean
    http://a1bambooflooring.com

    #
  15. show12345

    Tue Jun 24 11:27:53 BST 2014

    Critics still see the poet inside the poem, pressing the characters of the orphaned daughter with the absent mother and the lesbian alcoholic onto Bishop’s restrained, modest and graceful poems.

    something they've mentioned
    http://www.oregonlive.com/politics/index.ssf/2013/05/oregon_legislature_oks_instant.html

    #
  16. alexmen

    Wed Jun 25 13:47:47 BST 2014

    We are parents, children, spouses, significant others, friends, neighbors, employees and more! This week I am
    choosing to attach myself to some different stories:
    http://www.topagentmagazine.com/profiles/MarnieBennettWebFinal.pdf

    #
  17. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Thu Jun 26 08:12:38 BST 2014

    It should be noted that whilst ordering papers for sale at paper writing service, you can get unkind attitude.

    http://www.pinterest.com/marniebennett1/
    http://www.pinterest.com/marniebennett1/

    #
  18. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Sat Jun 28 14:09:15 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users

    click for the info
    http://digitaljournal.com/article/351030

    #
  19. show12345

    Sun Jun 29 13:15:30 BST 2014

    After I talked to the girl for a few minutes, I realized that she wanted to play me off as an ‘old fashioned’ against Erica Jong, and Adrienne (Rich) whom I like, and other violently feminist people. Which isn’t true at all.’

    http://firstcnaclasses.com

    #
  20. alexmen

    Mon Jun 30 09:15:11 BST 2014

    sites all over the internet, consider one of my long time favorite essays, Cows and Whales, an essay by a Japanese student who wrote the essay when I was teaching in the US.
    http://despreoptimizareseo.wordpress.com/

    #
  21. samad.khatri@yahoo.com

    Sun Jul 06 12:05:01 BST 2014

    important role in the making of any art, but art is art, and to separate writings, paintings, musical compositions, etc., into two sexes is to emphasize values in them that are not art.’http://ideeperilbagno.it

    #
  22. show12345

    Sat Jul 05 12:33:32 BST 2014

    which some see as premature frumpiness, others as sacrificial feminism – was something Bishop held dear throughout her poetic career. Her additional stipulation not to be included in all-female poetry anthologies is still adhered to today.

    social media search engine
    http://www.toptensocialmedia.com/social-media-business/ten-desirable-traits-of-social-media-managers/

    #
  23. show12345

    Tue Jul 01 06:23:23 BST 2014

    ‘Why should I be my aunt,/ or me, or anyone?’, while her famous love poem, ‘Shampoo’, is intimate but genderless, the lover in question a ‘friend,/ precipitate and pragmatical.’
    allphlebotomytraining.org - Find the best schools
    http://allphlebotomytraining.org/

    #
  24. show12345

    Wed Jul 02 09:41:04 BST 2014

    which some see as premature frumpiness, others as sacrificial feminism – was something Bishop held dear throughout her poetic career. Her additional stipulation not to be included in all-female poetry anthologies is still adhered to today.

    Veronica Walton
    http://quebecsocialiste.com

    #
  25. blackwater0002@gmail.com

    Thu Jul 03 09:03:18 BST 2014

    Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users

    Estelle Andrews
    http://ireland-pandoracharm.com

    #