Subscribe to Granta today

New Voices: Henry Marsh

|

New Voices highlights the best emerging talents on granta.com. The latest in the series is Henry Marsh, a brain surgeon turned memoirist, whose piece here describes an operation on the deeply buried pineal gland. You can also read an interview with the author below. Tomorrow we will publish a second New Voice for the online edition of Medicine.

Photo by Alex E. Proimos.

I often have to cut into the brain and it is something I hate doing. With a pair of short-wave diathermy forceps I coagulate a few millimetres of the brain’s surface, turning the living, glittering pia arachnoid – the transparent membrane that covers the brain – along with its minute and elegant blood vessels, into an ugly scab. With a pair of microscopic scissors I then cut the blood vessels and dig downwards with a fine sucker. I look down the operating microscope, feeling my way through the soft white substance of the brain, trying to find the tumour. The idea that I am cutting and pushing through thought itself, that memories, dreams and reflections should have the consistency of soft white jelly, is simply too strange to understand and all I can see in front of me is matter. Nevertheless, I know that if I stray into the wrong area, into what neurosurgeons call eloquent brain, I will be faced with a damaged and disabled patient afterwards. The brain does not come with helpful labels saying ‘Cut here’ or ‘Don’t cut there’. Eloquent brain looks no different from any other area of the brain, so when I go round to the Recovery Ward after the operation to see what I have achieved, I am always anxious.

There are various ways in which the risk of doing damage can be reduced. There is a form of GPS for brain surgery called Computer Navigation where, instead of satellites orbiting the Earth, there are infrared cameras around the patient’s head which show the surgeon on a computer screen where his instruments are on the patient’s brain scan. You can operate with the patient awake The idea that . . . memories, dreams and reflections should have the consistency of soft white jelly, is simply too strange to understand under local anaesthetic: the eloquent areas of the brain can then be identified by stimulating the brain with an electrode and by giving the patient simple tasks to perform so that one can see if one is causing any damage as the operation proceeds. And then there is skill and experience and knowing when to stop. Quite often one must decide that it is better not to start in the first place and declare the tumour inoperable. Despite these methods, however, much still depends on luck, both good and bad. As I become more and more experienced, it seems that luck becomes ever more important.

I had a patient who had a tumour of the pineal gland. The dualist philosopher Descartes, who argued that mind and brain are entirely separate entities, placed the human soul in the pineal gland. It was here, he said, that the material brain in some magical and mysterious way communicated with the mind and with the immaterial soul. I wonder what he would have said if he could have seen my patients looking at their own brains on a video monitor, as some of them do when I operate under local anaesthetic.

Pineal tumours are very rare. They can be benign and they can be malignant. The benign ones do not necessarily need treatment. The malignant ones are treated with radiotherapy and chemotherapy but can prove fatal nevertheless. In the past they were considered to be inoperable but with modern microscopic neurosurgery this is no longer the case: it is usually now considered necessary to operate at least to obtain a biopsy – to remove a small part of the tumour for a precise diagnosis of the type so that you can then decide how best to treat it. The biopsy result will tell you whether to remove all of the tumour or whether to leave most of it in place, and whether the patient needs radiotherapy and chemotherapy. Since the pineal is buried deep in the middle of the brain the operation is, as surgeons say, a technical challenge; neurosurgeons look with awe and excitement at brain scans showing pineal tumours, like mountaineers looking up at a great peak that they hope to climb. To make matters worse, this particular patient – a very fit and athletic man in his thirties who had developed severe headaches as the tumour obstructed the normal circulation of cerebro-spinal fluid around his brain – had found it very hard to accept that he had a life-threatening illness and that his life was now out of his control. I had had many anxious conversations and phone calls with him over the days before the operation. I explained that the risks of the surgery, which included death or a major stroke, were ultimately less than the risks of not operating. He laboriously typed everything I said into his smartphone, as if taking down the long words – obstructive hydrocephalus, endoscopic ventriculostomy, pineocytoma, pineoblastoma – would somehow put him back in charge and save him. Anxiety is contagious – it is one of the reasons surgeons must distance themselves from their patients – and his anxiety, combined with my feeling of profound failure about an operation I had carried out a week earlier meant that I faced the prospect of operating upon him with dread. I had seen him the night before the operation. When I see my patients the night before surgery I try not to dwell on the risks of the operation ahead, which I will already have discussed in detail at an earlier meeting. His wife was sitting beside him, looking quite sick with fear.

‘This is a straightforward operation,’ I said, with false optimism.

‘But the tumour could be cancerous, couldn’t it?’ she asked.

‘Well, it’s possible,’ I replied. ‘That’s why we’ll get a biopsy – it’s called a frozen section - during the op. If the pathologist says it’s not cancerous I don’t have to try to get every last little bit of tumour out. And if it’s a tumour called a germinoma I don’t have to remove the tumour at all and he can be treated with radiotherapy.’

‘So if it’s not cancer, and not a germinoma, then the operation is safe,’ she said, her voice tailing off uncertainly.

I hesitated, not wanting to frighten her but reluctant to make false promises. ‘Yes – it makes it a lot less dangerous if I don’t try to take it all out,’ I said, choosing my words carefully.

We talked for a little longer and then I wished them goodnight and went home.

I woke early on the morning of the operation and lay in bed thinking about the young mother I had operated on the previous week. I had operated on a tumour deep in the right side of her brain and somehow – I do not know how since the operation had seemed to proceed uneventfully – I had caused a major stroke, so that she awoke from the operation paralysed down the left side of her body. I had probably tried to take too much of the tumour out. I had probably strayed too deeply into her brain. I must have been too self-confident. I had been insufficiently fearful. I longed for this next operation, the operation on the pineal tumour, to go well – that there should be a happy ending, that everybody would live happily ever after, Neurosurgeons look with awe and excitement at brain scans showing pineal tumours, like mountaineers looking up at a great peak that they hope to climb. and that I could feel at peace with myself once again. But I knew that however bitter my regret, and however well the pineal operation went, there was nothing that I could do to undo the damage I had done to the young woman. I also knew that any unhappiness on my part was nothing compared to what she and her family were going through. I knew too that there was no reason why the next operation should go well just because I hoped so desperately that it would, or because the previous operation had gone so badly. The outcome of the pineal operation – whether the tumour was malignant or not, whether I could remove the tumour or whether it was hopelessly stuck to the brain and everything went horribly wrong – was largely outside my control. I also knew, however, that as time went by the grief I felt at what I had done to the young woman would fade. The memory of her lying in her hospital bed, her mother sitting beside her with her daughter’s newborn baby on her lap, would become a scar rather than a painful wound. She would be added to the list of my disasters – another headstone in that cemetery which the French surgeon Leriche once said all surgeons carry within themselves.

As soon as an operation begins, however, the surgeon usually finds that any morbid fear disappears. You take up the scalpel – no longer from the scrub nurse’s hand but, in accordance with some Health and Safety protocol, from a metal dish – and full of surgical self-confidence, press it precisely into the patient’s flesh. As the blood rises from the wound the thrill and excitement of the chase take over and you feel, more or less, in control of what’s happening. At least that is how it seems as the operation starts, and you operate in the blind faith that that is how the operation will continue, although you know that it may not.

My assistant and I stood behind the patient, who was propped upright in the sitting position, as we opened the back of his head, splitting the neck muscles apart and then drilling through the bone of his skull.

‘Really cool. Exciting,’ my registrar said.

‘Well,’ I replied, unable to deny my own excitement. ‘It’s like mountaineering – although it’s mountaineering for cowards since it’s not our lives that are at risk.’

The man’s head opened, the muscles retracted, the meninges incised and reflected – surgery has it own ancient descriptive language – I had the operating microscope brought in and I settled down in the operating chair. With this particular operation you are looking along a narrow crevice that separates the upper part of the brain – the cerebral hemispheres – from the lower part of the brainstem and cerebellum. You feel as though you are crawling through a long tunnel. At about three inches’ depth – although it feels a hundred times longer because of the microscope’s magnification – you will find the tumour. You are looking directly into the centre of the brain, a secret and mysterious place where all the most vital functions that keep us alive and conscious are to be found. Above you, like the great vault of a cathedral roof, are the deep veins of the brain – the Internal Cerebral Veins, and beyond them the basal veins of Rosenthal and then in the midline the Great Vein of Galen, dark blue and glittering in the light of the microscope, names that inspire awe in neurosurgeons, veins that carry huge volumes of venous blood away from the brain, and vessels which, if damaged, will result in the patient’s death.

In front of you is the granular red tumour and beneath it the tectal plate of the brainstem, where damage can produce permanent coma.

On either side are the posterior cerebral arteries that supply the parts of the brain responsible for vision. In the distance ahead, beyond the tumour, a door opened into a distant white-walled corridor once the tumour has been removed, is the third ventricle.

There is a fine, surgical poetry to these names which, combined with the beautiful optics of a modern, counter-balanced microscope, makes this one of the most wonderful neurosurgical operations – if all goes well, that is. The disastrous operation of the preceding week, however, had destroyed much of my It was as though I had lost all my knowledge and experience, and every time I divided a blood vessel I shook with fright. surgical self-confidence and I was as nervous as I had been when I had first become a surgeon. As I approached the tumour there were several blood vessels in the way that had to be cut – one needs to know which can be sacrificed and which cannot. It was as though I had lost all my knowledge and experience, and every time I divided a blood vessel I shook with fright. And yet as a neurosurgeon you learn at an early stage of your career to accept intense anxiety as a normal part of the day’s work and to carry on despite it – so eventually I reached the tumour. I removed a minute fragment of it which was then sent off to the pathology laboratory and I sat back in my operating chair.

‘We’ll now have to wait,’ I said to my assistant with a sigh. It is not easy to break off in the middle of an operation and I sat slumped in my chair, full of nervous excitement: longing to get on with the operation, hoping that my pathology colleague would report the tumour to be both benign and operable, hoping that the patient would live, hoping that I would be able to tell his wife after the operation that all would be well.

After forty-five minutes of waiting I couldn’t stand the delay any longer and, pushing my chair away from the operating table, leapt out of it and went to the nearest phone – still in my sterile gown and gloves. I rang the path lab and demanded to speak to the pathologist. There was a brief delay and then he came to the phone.

‘The frozen,’ I shouted. ‘What’s happening?’

‘Ah,’ he said imperturbably. ‘So sorry about the delay. I was in another part of the building.’

‘What the hell is it?’ I asked.

‘Yes. Well, I’m looking at it now. Ah! Yes, it looks like a straightforward benign pineocytoma . . . ’

‘Wonderful!’ I cried, forgiving him instantly. I went back to the operating table where everyone was patiently waiting.

‘Let’s get on with it!’ I said.

I scrubbed up again and climbed back into my operating chair, rested my elbows on the armrests and got back to work on the tumour. Each brain tumour is different – some are as hard as rock, some as soft as jelly. Some are completely dry, some pour with blood – sometimes to such an extent that the patient can bleed to death during the operation. Some shell out like peas from a pod, some are hopelessly stuck to the brain and its blood vessels. You can never know for certain from a brain scan exactly how a tumour will behave until you start to remove it. This man’s tumour was, as surgeons say, co-operative, and with a good surgical plane – in other words, it was not stuck to the brain. I slowly cored it out, collapsing the tumour in on itself away from the surrounding brain. After three hours it looked as though I had got most of it out.

Since pineal tumours are rare and exciting cases, one of my colleagues came into my theatre from his own operating theatre, to see how the operation was going. He was probably a little jealous. He peered over my shoulder.

The operation continued uneventfully and by the end it seemed that I had removed all, or almost all of the tumour without injuring any of the surrounding vital architecture of the brain. Since the tumour was a benign pineocytoma it probably would not matter even if post-operative scans showed I had left a small fragment of it behind. I left my assistant to close the wound and, leaving the operating theatres, walked the short distance to the wards.

I had only a few inpatients, one of them the young mother I had left paralysed one week earlier. I found her on her own in a side-room. Approaching a patient you have damaged makes the handle of the door You can never know for certain from a brain scan exactly how a tumour will behave until you start to remove it. behind which the patient is lying feel as though it is made of lead. There is a force-field pushing you away from the patient’s bed, resisting your attempts to raise a hesitant smile on your face. You are a villain and perpetrator, or at best incompetent, no longer heroic and all-powerful. It is difficult to know what role you now should play. It is much easier to hurry past the patient, looking busy and important, without saying anything at all.

I went into the room and sat down in the chair beside her.

‘How are you?’ I asked lamely.

She grimaced.

‘Not too good,’ she replied, pointing with her good right arm to her paralysed left arm and then lifting it up to let it fall lifeless onto the bed.

‘I’ve seen this happen before,’ I said. ‘And the patients got better, although it took months. I really do believe you will get largely better.’

‘I trusted you before the operation,’ she said. ‘Why should I trust you now?’

I had no immediate reply to this and could only look uncomfortably at my feet.

‘But I believe you,’ she said after a while, although I think she spoke out of pity.

I went back to the theatres. The pineal patient had been transferred from the table to a bed and was already awake. He lay with his head on a pillow, looking blearily around himself while one of the nurses washed blood and bone dust left from the operation out of his hair. The anaesthetists and theatre staff were laughing and chatting as they busied themselves around him, rearranging the many tubes and cables attached to him, in preparation for wheeling him round to the ITU. If he had not woken up so well they would have been working in silence.

‘He’s fine,’ my assistant happily shouted to me across the room.

I went to find his wife. She was waiting in the corridor outside the ITU, her face rigid with fear and hope as she watched me approach her.

‘It went as well we could hope,’ I said, in a formal and matter-of-fact voice, playing the role of a detached and brilliant brain surgeon – but then I could not help but reach out to her, to put my hands on her shoulders, and as she put her hands on mine and we looked into each others’ eyes, and I saw her tears, and had to struggle for a moment to control my own, I allowed myself a brief moment of celebration.

‘I think everything’s going to be all right,’ I said. ■

Interview with Henry Marsh:

Where did you learn to tell a story?

Until adolescence I read Grimms’ Fairy Tales, Malory’s Morte D’Arthur, the classical Greek myths and folk and fairy stories obsessively. Perhaps this gave me a feel for narrative structure.

Have you ever stolen a book?

Alas, yes, a chemistry textbook when at school from another boy so that I could then sell it secondhand for cash at Foyle’s in the Charing Cross Road. The fact I remember this very clearly fifty years later, even the boy’s name (whom I disliked) shows, I hope, a certain sense of shame. I don’t think I have ever stolen a book from a bookshop or from anybody else since then. I have stopped lending books to other people because they are never returned. There is a strange Ukrainian saying: ‘It is no crime to steal a man’s wife or his book.’

Where was the last place that changed your perspective on travel?

I have always had very mixed feelings about travel – the pleasure of it is largely the happiness of anticipation rather than actually arriving or being there. On the whole I deplore ‘holidays’. I travel abroad many times a year (preferably to obscure countries – I will be in Albania in two weeks’ time) but it is all related to work. One of the many privileges of being a doctor is that you can, if you want , find colleagues who become friends all over the world. My perspective changed twenty years ago when I met my colleague Igor in Ukraine and realized that I could combine travel with work, and no longer be a tourist. I could travel and be important! It has not changed since.

If you were in a band what would it be called?

I am old and grey and going bald, and although I am as silly as my patients and feel I am ‘young inside’ despite the evidence of the mirror and the difficulty getting out of bed in the mornings, I cannot imagine myself being in a band.

What’s your favourite bookshop?

I live in Oxford at weekends and haunt Blackwell’s. They used to send me solicitors’ letters threatening to sue me over my unpaid bills forty years ago when I was an undergraduate at the university and I would then sell the books back to them secondhand to pay off the bills. I prefer small bookshops in cathedral towns but there seem to be few left so I had better say Blackwell’s.

If you could cross into another artistic genre what would it be?

Woodblock engraving.

Do you know why you do it?

Do what? Writing? If writing, it is both to draw attention to myself but also to relieve the intense stress of my work. Every day at work is a human drama, often tragic – I do not want it to disappear unremarked. Surely so much excitement and suffering must mean something? If only a story?

What are you working on now?

Struggling to give a structure to all the stories I have written about my work over the last twenty years.

Comments (115)

You need to create an account or log in to comment.

  1. ijhjdsyn

    Thu Jan 09 12:08:37 GMT 2014

    Puteti gasi firme de inchirieri auto bucuresti http://www.inchirieri-masini-bucuresti.ro/inchirieri-auto/bucuresti.html in toate colturile lumii, astfel aveti posibilitatea sa explorati lumea mai in detaliu. http://www.auto-rent.ro/rent-a-car/bucharest.html

    #
  2. lav

    Mon Apr 08 20:13:32 BST 2013

    Dear Dr. Marsh:
    You are the most courageous surgeon I have heard of. Not only you find courage to perform incredibly complex operations but you go back to your patients regardless of the outcome: you talk to them, you think about them and share their pain. You are courageous to be so reflexive of your own practice and your impact on others. Reflexivity can be as painful as living a traumatic experience again and again but it is necessary to improve, to be more experience, to be a true expert. I wish you good health and lots of good luck in everything you do. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and your help with us! Cordially!

    #
  3. blatoya

    Thu Sep 11 09:38:43 BST 2014

    I simply wanted to thank you so much again. I am not sure the things that I might have gone through without the type of hints revealed by you regarding that situation.
    http://ragaminfo.freeblog.biz/kreasi-model-rumah-minimalis-sendiri/

    #
  4. blatoya

    Thu Sep 11 09:37:07 BST 2014

    And indeed, I’m just always astounded concerning the remarkable things served by you. Some 4 facts on this page are undeniably the most effective I’ve had.
    Model Rumah Minimalis
    http://ragaminfo.freeblog.biz/kreasi-model-rumah-minimalis-sendiri/

    #
  5. Yuan Ching Road EC

    Thu Sep 26 04:33:07 BST 2013

    Several buses are available near Yuan Ching Road EC along with shopping centers and restaurants. Yuan Ching Road EC is also Taman Jurong Shopping Centre as well as Taman Jurong Market and Food Centre. condolaunch.org/yuan-ching-road-ec

    #
  6. Sky Vue Bishan

    Mon Sep 16 03:07:41 BST 2013

    Bishan Condo is a new and upcoming new launch located in the Bishn area, nested right beside Bishan MRT. Sky Vue is within a short drive to Little India, Orchard and city area. With expected completion in mid 2017, it comprises of 694 units in total with 2 Blocks and 17 storeys. sky-vue.com.sg

    #
  7. Sky Vue Bishan

    Mon Sep 16 03:07:49 BST 2013

    Bishan Condo is a new and upcoming new launch located in the Bishn area, nested right beside Bishan MRT. Sky Vue is within a short drive to Little India, Orchard and city area. With expected completion in mid 2017, it comprises of 694 units in total with 2 Blocks and 17 storeys. sky-vue.com.sg

    #
  8. Cheeky92

    Fri Sep 20 20:04:14 BST 2013

    Thank you so much for this excellent post, as always you manage to both motivate me and excite me - good job and please do keep up the hard work - well all appreciate it very much! http://fullgamesfreedownload.com/gta-v-download-2013-full-pc-download-8-29-gb/
    http://e-cigreviewsite.com

    #
  9. 32416

    Wed Aug 28 13:20:44 BST 2013

    That write-up seemed to be wonderfully written and it also posesses a large amount of practical facts. I personally treasured ones specialized way of writing this particular posting. Thank you you've made this super easy to understand. http://clippingpathsource.com/

    #
  10. 32416

    Sun Sep 01 17:31:58 BST 2013

    Its amazing to see someone put so much passion into a subject. I’m glad I came across this. I’m glad I took the time to read on past the first paragraph. You’ve got so much to say, so much to offer. I hope people realize this and look into your page. http://clippingpathsource.com/

    #
  11. Nat4ever

    Fri Dec 07 01:14:43 GMT 2012

    Mr. Walsh-- I thoroughly enjoyed this essay! Please hurry and finish your book. I can't wait to read it!

    #
  12. J. Branson Skinner

    Thu Sep 06 05:53:54 BST 2012

    Thank you for your humbly beautiful account. The compassion captured in your writing and demonstrated in your actions is inspiring.

    #
  13. lucilesandra

    Sat Jan 11 04:02:38 GMT 2014

  14. teriharrington17

    Tue Oct 15 06:23:40 BST 2013

    Bishan Condo is a new and upcoming new launch located in the Bishn area, nested right beside Bishan MRT. Sky Vue is within a short drive to Little India, Orchard and city area. With expected completion in mid 2017, it comprises of 694 units in total with 2 Blocks and 17 storeys
    http://incentivespirometer.org

    #
  15. mattson

    Thu Oct 24 07:11:10 BST 2013

    Yup, there are lazy workers in all types of careers. You found one who's a professor! Good for you! I agree that this is a disgrace, but not the norm.
    http://www.vimaxpenispills.ca

    #
  16. Jurong West Condo

    Thu Oct 24 11:11:27 BST 2013

    Jurong West Condo will be accessible via Lakeside MRT station as well many of the buses along Boon Lay Way. http://condolaunch.org/jurong-west-condo

    #
  17. dorajackson

    Fri Nov 01 06:11:35 GMT 2013

    Those are astronomical hurdles to clear but, the measures make some important points and they warrant a closer look.
    http://hearthstonebetakeyz.blogspot.com

    #
  18. DouglasCarroll

    Mon Nov 04 07:44:34 GMT 2013

    Jurong West Condo will be accessible via Lakeside MRT station as well many of the buses along Boon Lay Way.\
    <a href="http://www.easyonlinepaydayloan.com">payday loans no credit check</a>

    #
  19. valoriegomez

    Tue Nov 05 06:33:22 GMT 2013

    Bishan Condo is a new and upcoming new launch located in the Bishn area, nested right beside Bishan MRT. Sky Vue is within a short drive to Little India, Orchard and city area. With expected completion in mid 2017, it comprises of 694 units in total with 2 Blocks and 17 storeys.
    http://www.winukcompetitions.co.uk/win-money

    #
  20. at.face

    Thu Nov 21 09:05:51 GMT 2013

    GOOD
    http://www.carinsurancerates.com/">car insurance</a>

    #
  21. ropesmy

    Fri Nov 22 05:50:43 GMT 2013

    nice
    <a href="http://www.easyonlinepaydayloan.com/">pay day loans</a>

    #
  22. ropesmy

    Fri Nov 22 05:51:08 GMT 2013

    nice
    <a href="http://www.easyonlinepaydayloan.com/">pay day loans</a>

    #
  23. tweetposh

    Mon Nov 25 04:33:54 GMT 2013

    GOOD
    <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SnMgW61ncM8">garcinia combogia</a>

    #
  24. Riverbank at Fernvale

    Tue Nov 26 02:27:16 GMT 2013

    Several buses are available near Sengkang West Way Condo along with shopping centers and restaurants. Sengkang West Way Condo is also near Waterway Point, the shopping, dining and entertainment hub which is scheduled to open in 2 years time. Also, it is right beside Punggol Waterfront. Entertainment for your loved ones and friends are therefore at your fingertips with the full condo facilities as well as the amenities near Sengkang West Way Condo. http://riverbankatfernvale.net

    #
  25. tweetposh

    Tue Nov 26 03:12:00 GMT 2013

  26. tweetposh

    Tue Nov 26 03:12:04 GMT 2013

  27. ChristiePage

    Mon Dec 02 13:07:43 GMT 2013

    Entertainment for your loved ones and friends are therefore at your fingertips with the full condo facilities as well as the amenities near Sengkang West Way Condo
    <a href="http://upperdivisionmarketing.com/">digital marketing arizona</a>

    #
  28. roarsmack

    Sat Jan 04 06:22:27 GMT 2014

  29. bellsy762

    Wed Dec 04 05:44:24 GMT 2013

  30. piesmedal

    Sat Jan 04 04:43:11 GMT 2014

    I live in Oxford at weekends and haunt Blackwell’s.
    http://www.personalcashadvance.com/

    #
  31. piesmedal

    Sat Jan 04 04:40:58 GMT 2014

    I live in Oxford at weekends and haunt Blackwell’s.
    http://www.personalcashadvance.com/

    #
  32. piesmedal

    Sat Jan 04 04:12:16 GMT 2014

    I live in Oxford at weekends and haunt Blackwell’s.
    http://www.personalcashadvance.com/

    #
  33. soresnot

    Mon Dec 09 05:45:16 GMT 2013

    In front of you is the granular red tumour and beneath it the tectal plate of the brainstem, where damage can produce permanent coma.
    http://howtotech.org/

    #
  34. uliannehope

    Mon Dec 09 05:51:44 GMT 2013

  35. terry718

    Tue Dec 10 04:43:57 GMT 2013

    Very good article, i enjoy reading this. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IVMpHQEAu8I

    #
  36. soresnot

    Tue Dec 10 09:02:39 GMT 2013

  37. soresnot

    Wed Dec 11 04:53:27 GMT 2013

  38. target

    Wed Dec 11 08:59:40 GMT 2013

    I like to articles like this. Good one! http://ejaculatiecontrole.nl

    #
  39. 37173

    Thu Dec 12 09:42:43 GMT 2013

    nice
    <a href-"http://pinterest.com/vidavacations/">vida vacations grand bliss</a>

    #
  40. lucilesandra

    Thu Dec 12 20:17:09 GMT 2013

    Outstanding Publish. Tооk а visit agаіn аnd thеre werе ѕоme terrific feedback оn thе website. Outstanding post. Keеp uр thе great work
    http://carauntuk-terbaru.blogspot.com/2013/10/tips-cara-menghilangkan-jerawat-dengan-cepat.html
    http://eighteenweeksofpregnant.blogspot.com/
    http://tomatoesbenefits.blogspot.com/

    #
  41. 37220

    Sat Dec 14 04:44:37 GMT 2013

    GOOD
    <a href="http://www.cuminggillespie.com/">calgary injury lawyer</a>

    #
  42. 37342

    Tue Dec 17 16:28:02 GMT 2013

  43. 37442

    Sat Dec 21 14:22:36 GMT 2013

  44. 37463

    Sun Dec 22 14:05:09 GMT 2013

    good
    <a href="http://www.appleloans.co.uk/bridgingloan">bridging finance explained</a>

    #
  45. 37446

    Sun Dec 22 17:43:59 GMT 2013

    great
    <a href="http://www.carinsurancerates.com/">car insurance comparison</a>

    #
  46. Archos

    Wed Dec 25 06:07:43 GMT 2013

    When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service? http://www.mp3music.us

    #
  47. piesmedal

    Fri Dec 27 05:16:47 GMT 2013

  48. Boardwalk

    Fri Dec 27 18:57:16 GMT 2013

    Not anyone could pull this off easily, we are talking about a very noble profession here with bloodied sightings daily as a norm. We have to respect you for that and if ever you need a sanctuary abode for your retreat, feel free to visit boardwalk residences @ http://www.boardwalk-residences.sg

    This place is surrounded by lush greenery landscaping and with a panoramic view of the calm and serene river for your meditation. Truly an escape from the stressful city living...

    #
  49. dhome

    Tue Aug 05 02:35:06 BST 2014

    "I often have to cut into the brain and it is something I hate doing" That is great advice, Thank you so much for such the wonderful post.

    From: http://dhome.vn/

    #
  50. StefanusNtep

    Mon Jan 06 17:53:05 GMT 2014

    What a great post, i enjoying reading your post, this give me a lot of idea especially for my next presentation. Thanks a lot for sharing dude.For more information about kemeja wanita, visit http://www.privatsteve.com

    #
  51. 2

    Mon Oct 13 22:20:05 BST 2014

    I was surfing net and fortunately came across this site and found very interesting stuff here. Its really fun to read. I enjoyed a lot. Thanks for sharing this wonderful information. http://vasectomycost0.wordpress.com/

    #
  52. Driving Jobs

    Fri Jul 18 19:54:30 BST 2014

    Logisticsjobshop.co.uk is the UK's leading online resource for Warehousing Jobs and Warehousing Recruitment. Logisticsjobshop.co.uk is dedicated to finding Warehousing Jobs for both Warehousing Managers and Warehousing Operatives. We are considered by many as the essential resource for employers and recruiters interested in Warehousing Recruitment.<a href="http://www.logisticsjobshop.co.uk/" title="driving jobs">driving jobs</a>

    #
  53. Rivertrees Residences

    Sun Jan 19 03:59:25 GMT 2014

    For vehicle owners, it takes less than 30 minutes to drive to the business hub and vibrant Orchard Road shopping district, via Tampines Expressway (TPE), Central Expressway (CTE) and Kallang-Paya Lebar Expressway (KPE). http://condolaunch.org/rivertrees-residences

    #
  54. Mike

    Sun Mar 02 07:36:30 GMT 2014

    Thanks for the information.
    more about <a href="http://proviantaudio.com/">Tips And Information</a>

    #
  55. Mike

    Sun Mar 02 07:37:06 GMT 2014

    Thanks for the information.
    more about <a href="http://proviantaudio.com/">Tips And Information</a>

    #
  56. kindsmiling

    Sat Mar 01 03:05:17 GMT 2014

  57. VSEO

    Sat Oct 11 14:42:13 BST 2014

    Auto Mobile Code
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DRPRY1dpACE

    Secret Millionaire Society
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FQEC9_t-f5o

    My Cash Bot
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULaVkwy251w

    Auto Mobile Binary
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WbD2UuM64j4

    Newbie Launch Formula
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0jjnjQGm_o0

    223 Average People Made $1857 A Day for 90 Days With This Cash Bot! Can YOU? Watch This Video NOW! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULaVkwy251w

    #
  58. Amelia Shay

    Wed May 28 01:16:21 BST 2014

    Thank you for this inspiring post.

    http://www.ziqmedia.com/

    #
  59. Jobs In Logistics

    Tue Oct 07 16:27:29 BST 2014

    There are huge opportunities and openings for people seeking either a career or www.jobs-inlogistics.co.uk Jobs In Logistics. It is a fascinating and diverse field that has many openings for those who possess the talent and skills. Jobs in logistics and Supply Chain involve managing networks of interconnected businesses to provide products and services as per customer requirements. It is the design, planning, execution, control and monitoring of activities related to the supply chain in order to create value and get competitive edge to compete globally.

    #
  60. kavin paker

    Tue Oct 14 14:55:09 BST 2014

    Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff. http://sixdegreeflow.jigsy.com/

    #
  61. wilkerson

    Fri Apr 25 07:07:05 BST 2014

    Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I genuinely enjoyed reading it, you are a great author. I will be sure to bookmark your blog and may come back very soon. I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great job, have a nice weekend.
    http://www.seminariruumid.com
    http://kaltsuvaibad.seinakellad.ee

    #
  62. Fabio Muher

    Tue Aug 26 16:56:14 BST 2014

    Find a Smartphone Reviews and Price,Tablet Reviews and Price,and other Electronic Items Review Product at this Web.
    <a href="http://www.smartsreview.com">http://www.smartsreview.com</a>

    #
  63. shosho

    Sun Oct 19 19:33:56 BST 2014

  64. Real Estate

    Tue Apr 08 05:07:59 BST 2014

    “Together, these two government assistance schemes, at $167 million, translated to about 36 percent of town councils’ operating expenses. This is quite substantial and helps reduce the financial burden on residents,” noted Mr Khaw. http://realestate-singapore.net/about-us

    #
  65. Eidinwell worry

    Tue Oct 07 02:45:03 BST 2014

    Free Download Driver All Printer

    Free Download All Driver Printer Canon,Driver Epson,Driver HP,Driver Samsung,etc

    http://zonedriverprinter.blogspot.com

    #
  66. langitbirushop

    Thu Aug 07 10:19:43 BST 2014

    thanks the info very helpful sir doctor

    http://langitbirushop.com/
    http://jamtangan-onlinemurah.com/

    #
  67. JOHN817726

    Sun Jul 20 23:20:48 BST 2014

    I want to thank you for this great article.I enjoyed every little bit
    part of it and I will be waiting for the new updates.Really loved
    reading your we blog post.
    http://www.liputan6.com

    #
  68. awengcelweng

    Thu Oct 02 18:19:27 BST 2014

    The Girlfriend Activation System: Christian H. Reveals His Little-Known Step-By-Step System Even Dorky, Awkward, And Ugly Guys Whose Claim To Fame Is Being "Horrible With Women" Are Using To Meet, Attract, And Ultimately Date Beautiful, Loyal, And Committed Girlfriends. Click here to visit Christian's official Girlfriend Activation System website

    http://obatfrigid.blogspot.com/2012/10/Obat-Perangsang-Wanita-Cepat-Alami.html
    http://bit.ly/merangsangwanita
    http://bit.ly/perangsangalami
    http://bit.ly/1ByXDEj
    http://bit.ly/1wVbJPw
    http://bit.ly/fbperangsang
    http://bit.ly/1rxuCWU
    http://bit.ly/1xv9m9d
    http://bit.ly/1vqUV3L
    http://bit.ly/1vqtrt2
    http://bit.ly/obatperangsang
    http://bit.ly/alatpembesar
    http://obatperangsangalami.webs.com/

    #
  69. Fabio Muher

    Fri Aug 15 09:20:14 BST 2014

    Download Software and Drivers Free
    This Blog Share About Download Software and Drivers Printer Canon,HP,Epson,Brother,Samsung,Dell,etc

    http://dosodrive.blogspot.com
    nice article brother...
    & don't forget please read vital info : http://www.smartsreview.com

    #
  70. reddotcondo

    Thu Sep 25 04:57:10 BST 2014

    District 9 condominium in Singapore, centrally located near MRT, Reputable Developer. Convenience and amenities. Contact us now, only at http://www.new-launch.com/property/sophia-hills/

    Sophia Hills Singapore

    #
  71. soponyono

    Thu Sep 25 02:37:17 BST 2014

    salam kenal admin, di tunggu kunjungan di toko onlie saya
    http://langitbirushop.com/
    http://jamtangan-onlinemurah.com/

    #
  72. vncamera247

    Mon Sep 08 05:52:25 BST 2014

  73. sant4

    Thu Oct 02 12:13:14 BST 2014

    I was surfing net and fortunately came across this site and found very interesting stuff here. Its really fun to read. I enjoyed a lot. Thanks for sharing this wonderful information. http://new-life10.blogspot.com/

    #
  74. Soundcreeps

    Wed Sep 17 00:16:51 BST 2014

    Soundcreeps Games
    Free PC Games, New PC Games, Best PC Games, Games Online, Top PC Games, Computer Games, PC Games ISO

    http://soundcreeps.blogspot.com/

    #
  75. friv4school

    Thu Sep 18 10:44:03 BST 2014

    playing friv4school games: http://friv4schoolonline.net

    #
  76. lisasviews

    Wed Sep 24 03:52:44 BST 2014

    well detailed and very nice post!
    http://freelivesexcams.us/

    #