Subscribe to Granta today

Lunch with the Surgeon

|

As the online edition of our Sex issue continues, novelist and critic Kapka Kassabova muses on what makes us attractive, and how we create attractiveness ourselves – with a little help from the scalpel. With images by Phil Toledano.

Last month, a plastic surgeon in Buenos Aires tried to seduce me. He was perfectly handsome and bronzed, with wavy hair and a Byronic shirt open at the chest to reveal a medallion featuring Michelangelo’s David. He’d invited me to his apartment for lunch. We drank red wine out of crystal-cut glasses, and he put on a DVD of a modern tango ballet which featured homoerotic scenes, for example a half-naked male dancer ‘tangoing’ with a long-legged table. All of the above led me to assume that he was gay – until he put his hand in a place that suddenly made me reconsider.

What I should have spotted straight away about this surgeon’s appearance and tastes was not his sexuality, but the fact that he worshipped physical perfection. Like almost everyone, I am extremely imperfect, so I shouldn’t have been surprised when he tried another tack.

‘I’ll give you a skin consultation,’ he declared, and I found myself in his consulting room, a bright light shining in my face. It’s not every day you get the chance to star in your own Botox soap opera.

‘Your face is perfect,’ he concluded.

‘Really?’ I said, strangely disappointed. ‘But what about these lines on my forehead, and these frown marks…’

‘No,’ he said and switched off the lamp. ‘I’m telling you, you are perfect.’ And he put his hand in the same place again.

He seemed genuinely hurt when I fled through the gilded lobby under the gaze of anatomically correct cherubs. The look on his face said, ‘I tell you that you’re perfect, and you’re still not impressed?’

*

The point here dear reader, is not to discuss dermatology. Nor is it to mock the friendly surgeon for trying it on with his lunch guest – after all, he put on a good show. The point is that he had sincerely meant ‘perfection’ as the ultimate compliment, and I had been sincerely disappointed. Why? Because in his world, the pursuit of perfection is the currency which has made him rich and his clients happy.

But his world is not my world. I always thought there was something wrong with the likes of Arnold Schwarzenegger, for instance. He looks too much like the idea of a perfect man, rather than an actual man. As Clive James put it once, he looks like ‘a brown condom filled with walnuts’.

There is something to be said about aliveness in all this. The opposite of attraction is repulsion, and they are both active states. I’m no stranger to the kind of physical attraction that turns your brain to pulp in thirty seconds, and I know that when we are physically attracted to someone, our desire feels alive, sometimes violently so. The person I desire has something that moves me (preferably in his direction). I could never feel neutral towards him. He may not have wavy hair and a perfect tan, but he will be marked with a particular, unrepeatable beauty – a crooked tooth in his smile, perhaps, or asymmetrical eyebrows. The air around him hums with the thrilling electricity of his being in the world as he is. Not as someone imagined him, or pumped him up in a gym, or modelled him with a scalpel.

What is beauty? In her study on beauty and attractiveness, Survival of the Prettiest, the American psychologist Nancy Etcoff argues that beauty may well be in the eye of the beholder – but that’s one biased, biological, big collective eye. In fact, we are all hard-wired to desire a certain range of facial and body features, regardless of our cultural make-up. Small chins, full lips, and lustrous hair are always attractive in women, studies show, just as a well-defined jaw and wide shoulders are always attractive in men. It’s something to do with oestrogen and testosterone, and other complex biological phenomena. But hear this: even male babies respond more warmly towards women who are judged attractive by this set of features, and you can argue with psychologists but you can’t argue with babies.

So, does that tell me what beauty is? No. With or without the full lips and the broad shoulders, in practice we all recognize it when we see it, and react to it with the most important parts of ourselves – our guts and our imaginations.

We also recognise what beauty isn’t, and this is why Mr Toledano’s photographs of surgically perfected people are so brilliantly disturbing.

Gina

The first thing I felt when I looked at these beings was a clinical chill, as if I was in Doctor Moreau’s lab where things had gone horribly wrong. As if, but not quite – because in fact, things here have gone horribly right.

We are in a world of anatomical hyperbole here. The breasts are too breasty. The lips are too labial, the cheekbones too sculpted. The eyebrows are too arched and the muscles are too brawny. I look hard, but can’t find anything personal in these persons to remember them with. They are specimens preserved in the museum of their own desire. They are the offspring of a bank account coupled with a tragic misunderstanding, more on which in a moment.

Steve

Unlike most of us, with our flawed faces and bodies moulded by the passage of time, ‘Steve’ and ‘Gina’ are moulded by the surgeon’s hand. Their primary sexual characteristics are so hyper-real that they tip over into sexual ambiguity. It is the extremeness of Steve’s masculinity that makes him suspect as a man. It’s the over-planned positioning of Gina’s breast swellings that makes her look so unlike a woman.

Apart from their medical history, these bodies don’t tell any story – because the past has been wiped away. There is nothing left to the imagination here, because they are already imagined. In this sense, they are pornographic. As with the bodies in pornography, where we know exactly what is going to happen, nothing is at stake here, because we know exactly what has happened. The result is an anti-climax. Despite the frantic action, pornography is static. Despite all the perfectly pert swellings on these bodies, they are strangely inert. Instead of suspense, there’s silicone.

But then I look at the eyes, and I see something startling. I see the story behind the blank flesh. The precise point where the pornography of desire turns to Faustian metaphysics. And this is Mr Toledano’s artistic achievement. Steve’s, Gina’s, and the other models’ eyes are the only remaining place that expresses something personal about them. What I read in them is in turn defiance, pride, hope, sadness, fear, loneliness, and a desperate plea. In other words, the stuff you can find in most people’s eyes; but most people’s eyes don’t sit on top of bodies that have been sliced and stitched so much in order to become themselves.

‘Please,’ they say, ‘Please desire me. Please fantasise about me. Please admire me. And please, finally, consume me.’ To hear yourself say No to this plea – as you inevitably will, unless you’re a pervert – is sad. So much hope, so much self-hate, and so much silicone have gone into these creations. The stakes are, in fact, exceedingly high, and the overall impact of these photos is one of deep existential sadness. Creatureliness is, alas, not sexy, unless you’re in Avatar.

*

Remember the moment when Faust finally achieves perfect happiness, and therefore perfect stasis? That is also the moment he gives the Devil access to his soul, according to their devilish pact, and instantly surrenders his mortality and his humanity. This is what is happening here – the moment of unnatural perfection is not the moment when you become yourself. It’s when you stop being yourself. If nothing can touch you, not even time, what chance is there that a human hand will want to do it?

This is why, my dear surgeon, perfection is not a compliment. It’s a diagnosis for which there is no treatment. It’s engineered in the mortician’s lab, where cosmetic surgeons dwell.

Surely you know – from the medallion around your neck – that the point about Michelangelo’s David is not that he is perfect. The point is that – five centuries on – he is still inimitably, naturally, adorably human.

Both photos © Mr Toledano, from ‘A New Kind of Beauty’

Comments (72)

You need to create an account or log in to comment.

  1. AliMoen

    Wed Jun 02 07:47:00 BST 2010

    So naively correct... Perfection is anatomical deception... A diversion from "essence" to "being" only.

    #
  2. Margie

    Thu Jun 03 16:28:20 BST 2010

    A chilling look at self destruction through perfection.

    #
  3. jack89

    Fri Jan 16 14:58:20 GMT 2015

    If the best thing to write, but from reading this article it really helps. Great post http://www.benzyseo.es

    #
  4. Aqibarif741@gmail.com

    Sun Feb 16 12:09:09 GMT 2014

    Your page is sweet, your graphics are great, and what's more, you use videos that are relevant to what you're saying. You're definitely one in a million, man!
    http://www.contactnumbers.co/o2-customer-service-contact-number o2 number

    #
  5. AsharSeo

    Mon Mar 02 07:30:51 GMT 2015

    All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you werent too busy looking for attention....

    Canadian border with DUI

    http://www.theepochtimes.com/n3/blog/legal-troubles-keeping-you-from-traveling-to-canada/

    #
  6. Micheal

    Sat Feb 15 08:41:09 GMT 2014

    great work, thanks for sharing such a great post. Thumb Up http://www.brilliantassignments.com/cheapest-research-paper-writing-service/

    #
  7. Jake Tire

    Fri Nov 29 23:06:45 GMT 2013

    Great post, I think that both of these models represent the epitomy of beauty. http://www.starfiretires.net

    #
  8. Aqibarif741@gmail.com

    Sun Mar 30 12:45:00 BST 2014

    You could post on the critiquing for the blog. You may vend it's astounding. Your blog ideas might add to your yield.
    http://www.pinterest.com/bubblegumcastin bubblegum casting

    #
  9. davidjames

    Wed Oct 22 16:35:55 BST 2014

    I came onto your blog while focusing just slightly submits. Nice strategy for next, I will be bookmarking at once seize your complete rises
    Merle Flores
    SNOWBOOTSJPN.COM

    #
  10. Aqibarif741@gmail.com

    Sun Feb 16 10:24:17 GMT 2014

    You might comment on the demonstration of the blog. You should say that it's first-class. Your blog recap shall swell up your capital.

    http://www.contactnumbers.co/british-gas-contact-phone-number

    british gas contact number

    #
  11. zararaza1@hotmail.com

    Fri May 30 11:30:12 BST 2014

    I am a antique ’Article’ collector and I sometimes read some new articles if I find them interesting. And I found this one pretty fascinating and it should go into my collection. http://www.slidingdoorcc.com/

    #
  12. Aqibarif741@gmail.com

    Sun Feb 16 09:42:44 GMT 2014

    Thanks may have not intended to do so, but I think you have managed to express the state of mind that a lot of people are in. The sense of wanting to help, but not knowing how or where
    http://www.contactnumbers.co/orange-customer-service-contact-number orange number

    #
  13. Daryl J

    Thu Dec 26 16:11:42 GMT 2013

    These don't really match real life people. They look almost machine like. http://www.aircompressorreviewsplace.com/

    #
  14. Silvex

    Thu Feb 19 15:38:50 GMT 2015

    Thanks this interesting article! A plastic surgeon will probably be attracted to beauty a lot more than any other human being. If you want you can take a look at my website about plastic surgery: http://www.celebsurgerysecrets.com/ then feel free to do so. The plastic surgeon in this story will probably fancy the website as well ;).

    Kind regards!

    #
  15. ajohn1070aaa

    Wed Dec 31 06:30:39 GMT 2014

    Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have.seo
    https://www.fiverr.com/james_seo/give-you-20-links-of-pr5-and-pr6-just

    #
  16. Aqibarif741@gmail.com

    Sat Feb 15 14:53:46 GMT 2014

    Information very useful! I've been looking for books of this nature for a way too long. I'm just glad that I found yours.
    http://www.contactnumbers.co/virgin-media-customer-service-contact contact virgin media

    #
  17. Jeparaonline

    Sun Mar 01 16:06:14 GMT 2015

    Toko mebel online http://MebelJeparaKarya.wordpress.com dan
    toko furniture http://goo.gl/EgLeQz dan
    mebel jepara Murah http://Mebelonlinejepara.blogspot.com dan
    Mebel Jepara Minimalis http://goo.gl/t2SFz dan
    Toko furniture online http://Jeparaonline.angelfire.com dan
    toko furniture http://goo.gl/YWciCq dan
    Jeara Online http://Jeparaonline.weebly.com dan
    Jepara Online http://goo.gl/VdxWcp dan
    Kursi Jati http://Kursi-tamujati.blogspot.com dan
    Kursi Tamu Jati http://goo.gl/Og21fa dan
    Furniture Jati http://furniturekujatijepara.blogspot.com dan
    Furniture Jati Mebel http://goo.gl/zuCq7x dan
    Mebelku Jati Jepara http://mebelkujatijepara.blogspot.com dan
    Mebel Jati Jepara http://goo.gl/un9i9v dan
    Kursi Minimalis Murah http://kursitamujatimurah.blogspot.com/ dan
    Kursi Murah http://goo.gl/FyoMbd dan

    Toko Mebel Online http://www.jeparaonline.org dan
    jepara meubel = http://goo.gl/BeBnTr dan
    Toko Mebel Jepara Online http://www.jeparameubel.com dan
    mebel kursi = http://goo.gl/cen0R dan
    Toko Mebel Kursi http://www.mebelkursi.com dan
    karya funriture = http://goo.gl/5HXlC dan
    Toko Furniture Karya http://www.karyafurniturejepara.com dan
    karya priboemi = http://goo.gl/ve5x67 dan
    Toko Furniture Priboemi http://www.karyapriboemijepara.com dan
    jepara on = http://goo.gl/av4fD dan
    Kursi #

  18. Olivia_P

    Wed Feb 25 06:19:11 GMT 2015

    Thank you, I've been seeking for info about this subject matter for ages and yours is the best I have discovered so far.
    http://americanresidentialwarranty.com/home-warranty/

    #
  19. zararaza1@hotmail.com

    Thu May 29 07:19:20 BST 2014

    You're so cool! I don't think I've read anything like this before. So good to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. Thanks for starting this up. http://www.murdocksolon.com/

    #
  20. Pure Essay

    Thu Oct 16 12:00:26 BST 2014

    Nice pictures thanks for the share..
    http://www.pureessay.com/

    #
  21. Aqibarif741@gmail.com

    Tue Feb 25 23:37:46 GMT 2014

    Thanks may have not intended to do so, but I think you have managed to express the state of mind that a lot of people are in. The sense of wanting to help, but not knowing how or where
    https://www.rebelmouse.com/brianrobbensresparktheromance respark the romance book review

    #
  22. Aqibarif741@gmail.com

    Sun Feb 16 14:26:38 GMT 2014

    Have read a couple of of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorites blog website list and will probably be checking back soon.
    http://www.contactnumbers.co/scottish-power-contact-number scottish power contact number

    #
  23. Aqibarif741@gmail.com

    Sat Feb 15 16:04:18 GMT 2014

    That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this. This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great article.
    http://www.contactnumbers.co/npower-contact-telephone-number npower contact

    #
  24. Aqibarif741@gmail.com

    Sat Feb 15 15:30:10 GMT 2014

    You can write about the tips on the blog. You might relinquish it's fascinating. Your blog recommendations may thicken your commissions.

    http://www.contactnumbers.co/talk-talk-customer-service-contact talktalk contact

    #
  25. Anuj Kumar

    Sat Feb 14 10:00:05 GMT 2015

    Professional packers and movers Pune centered organizations present entrance to entrance product packaging and moving remedy to their customers.

    Packers and Movers in Chennai or
    http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-chennai/
    Packers and Movers in Delhi or
    http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-delhi/
    Packers and Movers in Gurgaon or
    http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-gurgaon/
    Packers and Movers in Pune or
    http://packersmoverspune.top3rd.in/

    #
  26. Anuj Kumar

    Sat Feb 14 10:00:15 GMT 2015

    Packers and Movers in Hyderabad Or
    http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-hyderabad/
    Packers and Movers in Mumbai or
    http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-mumbai/
    Packers and Movers in Bangalore Or
    http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-bangalore/

    #
  27. Richard

    Mon Jun 09 07:00:07 BST 2014

    Great post ! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. http://www.absoluteessays.com/can-i-pay-to-do-my-essay/

    #
  28. Harry

    Mon Jun 09 08:39:27 BST 2014

    you've done this post quite well and it was a great read.
    http://www.getessaypaper.com/professional-paper-writers-for-hire/

    #
  29. Olivia_P

    Wed Mar 04 06:29:43 GMT 2015

    This is also a very good post which I really enjoyed reading. It is not everyday that I have the possibility to see something like this.
    http://kitchendoorcabinets.com/

    #
  30. Olivia_P

    Wed Mar 04 06:31:00 GMT 2015

    We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work.
    http://www.webseobuy.com/cms.php?id=5

    #
  31. allsizejackets

    Mon Jun 09 11:26:08 BST 2014

    nice clicks, such a creative work you have done
    http://www.allsizejackets.com

    #
  32. allsizejackets

    Mon Jun 09 11:26:08 BST 2014

    nice clicks, such a creative work you have done
    http://www.allsizejackets.com

    #
  33. Olivia_P

    Wed Mar 04 11:41:05 GMT 2015

    A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work.
    https://highpagerankbacklnks.wiki.zoho.com/STEPS-TO-AVOID-DROP-IN-KEYWORD%E2%80%99s-RANKING-ON-GOOGLE.html

    #
  34. Olivia_P

    Wed Mar 04 06:31:39 GMT 2015

    This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, These type of articles keeps the users interest in the website, and keep on sharing more ... good luck.
    http://www.granta.com/New-Writing/Lunch-with-the-Surgeon

    #
  35. Olivia_P

    Fri Feb 27 07:07:54 GMT 2015

    We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work.
    http://americanresidentialwarranty.com/what-we-do/

    #
  36. Celebguy

    Wed Jun 25 06:07:29 BST 2014

    Thanks for this post, Thinking about models of beauty of our society. I stumbled upon this site: http://surgerystars.com/ it made me think a lot about the role of celebrities in the models of beauty our society encourages.

    #
  37. jack89

    Thu Jan 01 12:58:39 GMT 2015

    They actively share the reasons why their own children are vaccinated, and promote that choice to their families and friendshttp://seoservicebarcelona.es

    #
  38. chief essays

    Fri Oct 17 11:57:30 BST 2014

    You have done great work and I appreciate your work. I like it.Thanks for sharing. http://www.chiefessays.com/pay-to-do-assignment/

    #
  39. Najib 2

    Sat Feb 28 21:14:15 GMT 2015

    http://www.narutoshippuden.org/ is the a manga website where you can read manga and watch anime like Naruto and Bleach everyday

    #
  40. AsharSeo

    Fri Feb 13 06:07:45 GMT 2015

    When COM Automotive Mechanics carries out a major service we check, test, replace and repair the required parts to make your car feel like new again...
    neuroflexyn
    https://www.facebook.com/neuroflexyn.reviews

    #
  41. AsharSeo

    Fri Feb 13 06:23:08 GMT 2015

    I would be most grateful to hear. Even if you want to just tell me your experience that would be great.
    3 credit reports

    http://mywheel.net/free-credit-reports-from-all-3-bureaus-comparability

    #
  42. AsharSeo

    Mon Feb 23 09:51:43 GMT 2015

    You might comment on the order system of the blog. You should chat it's splendid. Your blog audit would swell up your visitors...

    turbo force

    https://www.facebook.com/suplemento.turbo.force

    #
  43. PSID

    Fri Aug 29 22:56:19 BST 2014

    What an interesting read. These ancient renderings of plastic surgery is something else.

    I came across this site: http://plasticsurgeryid.com/ and it got me to think a lot about the role that celebrities play in our society.

    Kind of scary! No?

    #
  44. AsharSeo

    Sun Feb 22 10:21:08 GMT 2015

    I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great job, have a nice weekend.

    ganoderma
    http://reishi.ganodermausa.com/

    #
  45. anderson.silly

    Sat Sep 20 09:27:11 BST 2014

    There are many Hollywood Celebrities that have gone through the plastic Surgery to make themselves more beautiful so here on this website the complete list of Celebrities with their Pictures are available here.
    http://www.beforeandafterceleb.com/

    #
  46. AsharSeo

    Sun Feb 22 05:56:09 GMT 2015

    I found your blog via Google while searching for such kinda informative post and your post looks very interesting for me...

    april birthstone diamond

    http://gemstone-magic.com/gemstones-guide/bloodstone/top-10-ways-use-bloodstones-healing-purposes/

    #
  47. jack89

    Fri Jan 09 14:23:47 GMT 2015

    I like it, for that I say thank you personally. Our greetings from. http://www.bestbacklinksusa.com

    #
  48. ASADALI11122

    Sat Sep 27 18:00:50 BST 2014

    You might comment on the personal credibility of the blog. You should index it's marvelous. Your blog feelings should accelerate your colleagues.
    <a title="blog comments" href="http://www.fiverr.com/aqibarif74/welcome-this-gig-60-high-pr-blog-comment-on-backlinks-dofollow-maunally-but-very-very-low-external-link-only">blog comments</a>

    #
  49. jack89

    Sat Jan 10 13:12:15 GMT 2015

    Actually I read it yesterday but I had some thoughts about it and today I wanted to read it again because it is very well written http://www.bocamoverseasy.com

    #
  50. Celebguy

    Mon Nov 24 22:18:00 GMT 2014

    I really loved this article, for those interested in plastic surgery of the famous you should really check
    : http://www.surgeryvip.com

    Thanks for this!

    #
  51. anderson.silly

    Thu Nov 06 10:21:43 GMT 2014

    You have explained everything no nicely that is really awesome..
    http://www.cricketworldcup2015schedule.com/
    http://www.easywomenhairstyles.com/

    #
  52. Olivia_P

    Sat Feb 28 06:13:12 GMT 2015

    A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work.
    http://www.webseobuy.com/

    #
  53. Olivia_P

    Sat Feb 28 06:09:45 GMT 2015

    I am just pretty happy to sign up ones own guestbook these days,Your own feedback and listed below are excellent in my opinion,incidentally I should say also definitely will teach some great supplements for your needs every.
    www.gardenwarriors.net/biological-solutions/garden-ladybugs.html

    #
  54. Olivia_P

    Sat Feb 28 06:10:58 GMT 2015

    You have a very inspiring way of exploring and sharing your thoughts. It is very uncommon nowadays, lots of sites and blogs having copy pasted or rewritten info. But here, no doubt, info is original and very well structured. Keep it up.
    http://www.minitruckusa.com/

    #
  55. Corleonre3

    Sat Nov 15 17:11:57 GMT 2014

    http://piraterclashofclans.fr/

    Comme un spectacle de football, le football pur, il n'a pas été excellent. Mais, comme un spectacle de deux groupes de joueurs qui ne veulent pas céder d'un pouce. . . il était fascinant. Ils voulaient sauter plus haut, plus fort attaquer, courir plus vite. Et les fans ont fait une occasion ".
    Ce moment de finesse était assez sur une nuit où la balle était aussi sauvage que l'ambiance dans le stand.

    #