Subscribe to Granta today

Necessary Daemons


Photo by Mark Robinson.

Yesterday I saw Werner Herzog’s Cave of Forgotten Dreams. It was the first 3D movie I had ever seen in my life and, though I’m sure it was a much less aggressive use of the technology than normal, I found it disorienting in this way: the illusory extension of space between my two eyes seemed to pry apart the frontal lobes of my brain, to peel them back toward the stem where the older parts of brain structure still are – the bits we share with the prehistoric people who made the paintings in the Chauvet cave. I kept slipping in and out of consciousness. Better perhaps to say that I was uncertainly balanced between consciousness and some other state in which flashes of dream and archaic intuition kept flowing in and out of the voices from the film and the images of painted animals moving over the contours of rock on the cave walls. I was a little frustrated because I had wanted to see this film for a long time and I wanted to have the full experience of being in the cave.

But maybe that was the full experience of being in the cave.

I make up stories for a living, make them up and write them down, and for a long time I have claimed, on suitable occasions, that my work is dictated to me by daemons, being careful to include that extra ‘a,’ so that the daemons I’m invoking may seem at least morally neutral, not out and out evil as single ‘e’ demons are mostly considered to be.

There’s been a vogue for angels lately, but somehow I like daemons better.

Artists and writers don’t necessarily have to believe that spirits like that are really out there—inspiration can as easily be understood as a process of reflection within the individual psyche. But somehow I like my daemons better.

Any writer who has ever written well is aware of a sweet spot in the consciousness where imagination and expression cooperate seamlessly and seem to become effortless. A flow state, it’s sometimes called. The problem is getting there, and getting there reliably, day after working day. For that, many writers have rituals, most of them so mundane they are not recognizable as magical acts. There’s been a vogue for angels lately, but somehow I like daemons better. Sharpening a certain number of a certain kind of pencil – that sort of thing. There are extreme variations, such as Graham Greene going down to the street to look for a particular combination on a license plate of a passing car, before he could begin to write on any given day. (One imagines weeks or months going by . . . ) Across the spectrum from strange to banal, these rituals are all about invoking the, well . . . muse – not that most writers in the twentieth-first century believe in the literal existence of muses, any more than they’d be believe in fairies or Santa Claus. Or daemons.

In the mid 1980s I had a few sessions of therapeutic hypnosis that made me understand that the writer’s flow state was really a light hypnotic trance, and that writers’ rituals were a means of self-induction – self-hypnosis, unconsciously practiced more often than not. A key to imagination’s door . . . I wrote a novel (Doctor Sleep) about a hypnotist that also involves some of the more extreme possibilities of auto-hypnosis, such as multiple personality disorder. The model of spirit possession turns out to fit the phenomena of multiple personality syndrome pretty well (e.g. total suppression of the ego for a time and inability of the ego to remember afterward what the alternate personality, or possessing spirit, has done). It’s a two-way street: you can believe that hypnosis explains and reduces all such experiences, or you can believe (as the religious do) that the daemons are out there, and sometimes come in . . .

Did Ivan Karamazov really get a visit from the devil, or was it only brain fever?

Most religions have in them somewhere an element of spirit possession, close to a mystical core. I have been going to Quaker meetings lately, where there is no rite or ritual whatsoever; where the congregation sits quietly for an hour, waiting in silence for the Holy Spirit to move any individual to speech. In our time the only other religion I know of that offers such extraordinary empowerment to the individual practitioner is . . . Haitian Vodou.

Strange comparison, I know. The lwa, the spirits of the Haitian tradition, are courted much more elaborately than in Quaker meetings, and with a lot more noise and movement too: Possession, in the Haitian context, can be kind of rough, the first time or two. Frightening. Terrifying, even. drumming and chanting and dancing – all directed toward the induction of trance. Possession, in the Haitian context, can be kind of rough, the first time or two. Frightening. Terrifying, even. You feel what you think of as your self being peeled away like the husk from a fruit. Your brain splits open, back to its most ancient core. And away off in the dark someone is screaming the most blood-chilling screams and you become aware that those screams are coming from your body – but you are not in your body any more . . .

Afterward, the most blissful and peaceful euphoria – what typically follows a strong and violent catharsis.

Most religions are out to free the practitioner from the prison of the self. That requires displacement of the ego. The ego may be lulled into inattention, which is what I believe occurs in the Society of Friends, or it can simply be snatched out of the saddle. In the latter case, the terror one feels is caused by simian claws of the ego clinging to its place with all its might, tearing shreds from your being as it’s dragged away howling – an experience I sometimes like to call la déchirure.

Some say, it is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living god.

Truth to tell, possession in Haiti Vodou is often, maybe more often than not, much milder than that, especially for experienced practitioners. A seasoned serviteur can move from one state to the other by looking for a few seconds into the flame of a butane lighter. A writer can get to the right place by sharpening one or two special pencils.

I want to be there because I want my ego out of the way when ‘I’ am writing. When writing is writing. I want the spirit that moves the story to pass cleanly through me on to the page, thence into the mind of the reader, without any conscious interference from my own personality. Because I get a better story that way. And because I also get all the benefits of the strong catharsis, once the story has been told.

A few years ago I had a sort of counseling conversation with a Haitian writer I had known for several years – one of the mostI want the spirit that moves the story to pass cleanly through me on to the page, thence into the mind of the reader, without any conscious interference from my own personality. brilliant and most tormented writers I have ever read. She had daemons, plenty of them, and she had to wrestle them, like Jacob, every day. The thing that I told her that seemed to be helpful was, tu es au service de l’histoire; that is, you are at the service of the story. In the Haitian cultural context, the resonance of this sort of statement is deep. Vodou practitioners call themselves serviteurs, rather than believers or worshippers, and the service they offer is, through their own heads and bodies, a passage for the lwa to travel from the invisible to the material world, where they can interact with human beings in the flesh.

Something of the sort went on in the Chauvet cave. We know that, though we have no way of knowing. The images themselves are an uncrackable code. We know it from our daemons, or from the more ancient parts of our brains, and because the evidence is everywhere in human experience, not only when drums begin in Vodou ceremonies, or when Friends assemble quietly in a meeting hall, but also when any artist picks up an instrument and aims it at a surface meant to be transformed.

One of the people Herzog interviews in the film is a young man with a ponytail who had once been a juggler, and who remembered seeing (in person or on film, I don’t recall) an Australian aborigine who still did a little stone-painting once in a while. I am relying on my own memory now, and though it’s a memory from yesterday, memory is a daemon too . . . sometimes a daemon of deception.

The stone-painter was asked, ‘Why are you painting now?’

And he replied, ‘I am not painting. Now Spirit is painting.’ ■

Read an extract from Madison Smartt Bell’s new novel, Out of the Tombs, here.

Comments (25)

You need to create an account or log in to comment.

  1. christine

    Wed Oct 19 16:35:30 BST 2011

    Very nice. Jean Clottes posits a theory about the negative hand prints found near the paintings: they were attempts by the shaman to become part of the cave (he would paint over his hand so that it would disappear into the cave surface). A different way of achieving flow, maybe?

  2. christine

    Wed Oct 19 17:07:18 BST 2011

    Duplicated comment removed.

  3. CinderellaBeaulieu

    Sun Dec 15 15:00:18 GMT 2013

    I want the spirit that moves the story to pass cleanly through me on to the page, thence into the mind of the reader, without any conscious interference from my own personality. Because I get a better story that way. waht is this?
    "">vida vacation club reviews</a>

  4. learner

    Fri Jan 03 03:30:22 GMT 2014

    Hypnosis often involves techniques which already exist such as regression therapy, but even better is if you know self-hypnosis. Hypnosis is natural, it's no magic.

  5. Steve Jame

    Mon Dec 08 17:26:30 GMT 2014

    Oh my goodness! Awesome article dude! Thank you, However I am encountering issues with your RSS. I don’t understand why I am unable to join it. Is there anybody getting identical RSS issues? Anyone that knows the answer can you kindly respond? Thanks!!

  6. Steve Jame

    Sun Dec 14 19:31:44 GMT 2014

    This really is this kind of a awesome resource that you're offering and you give it away for totally free. I take pleasure in seeing sites that realize the value of supplying a prime resource for absolutely free. I truly loved reading your post.

  7. berita bola

    Fri Aug 08 12:24:44 BST 2014

    berita info formasi penerimaan pendaftaran cpns 2014 online Liputan6 hari ini
    berita lowongan cpns 2014 Liputan6 hari ini
    berita bkn pusat Liputan6 hari ini
    berita pln Liputan6 hari ini
    berita Ignasius Jonan Liputan6 hari ini
    berita harga bensin pertamax Liputan6 hari ini
    berita harga bbm naik Liputan6 hari ini
    berita kenaikan gaji pns 2014 Liputan6 hari ini
    berita skk migas Liputan6 hari ini
    berita jamsostek Liputan6 hari ini

  8. Jhontor

    Wed Mar 05 18:25:17 GMT 2014

    Really nice and interesting post. I'm looking for this kind of information and enjoyed reading this one. Thank you for sharing.

  9. Bill179

    Tue Mar 25 13:19:45 GMT 2014

  10. Steve Jame

    Sun Dec 14 11:16:12 GMT 2014

    The deliberate attempt to contact the spirit of a deceased person is known as necromancy, or in spiritism as a séance.

  11. Alberta

    Thu Dec 11 04:42:38 GMT 2014

    Thank you for your post, I look for such article a long time, today I finally find it. This post gives me lots of advice it is very useful for me.

  12. Steve Jame

    Sun Dec 14 07:56:19 GMT 2014

    This is a very good tip particularly to those new to the blogosphere. Simple but very accurate info… Appreciate your sharing this one. A must read post!
    grow taller 4 idiots video download

  13. Steve Jame

    Sat Dec 06 16:11:04 GMT 2014

    wow, great, I was wondering how to cure acne naturally. and found your site by google, learned a lot, now i’m a bit clear. I’ve bookmark your site and also add rss. keep us updated.


    Tue Jun 17 14:43:14 BST 2014

    workers can constantlyThe greatest cost-effective commitment is in enhancing job-related capabilities so that the present workers can constantlyIt has no way of it. But there is another part of attention that not only can.

  15. Steve Jame

    Sat Nov 29 10:04:02 GMT 2014

    I liked the content you have given here. Very informative.
    voyance par tel


    Sat Aug 16 14:57:36 BST 2014

    Excellent Understand Personally, This is just what We needed. Cheers Regarding phrase providing this great write-up! That's very intriguing Smile I like reading in addition to We are always try trying to find beneficial information similar to this!

  17. Steve Jame

    Tue Dec 09 12:28:17 GMT 2014

    This is a good post! Well done and I believe it will be better in future. May wanna add some pictures and life.

  18. ErinaJones

    Wed Dec 17 04:30:20 GMT 2014

    I was surfing net and fortunately came across this site and found very interesting stuff here. Its really fun to read. I enjoyed a lot. Thanks for sharing this wonderful information.

  19. Steve Jame

    Wed Dec 03 10:37:30 GMT 2014

    You may post on the quotes for the blog. You could tell how it's brand new. Your blog thoughts will springboard your participates.

  20. Steve Jame

    Wed Dec 03 11:49:30 GMT 2014

    This is really what I was searching for. I am feeling joyful to came here.I would like to thank you for sharing such info with us,I like to advise you that Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well.
    get the girl code michael fiore guide

  21. Mitsodimi365

    Mon Sep 15 13:36:52 BST 2014

    Take up one idea. Make that one idea your life - think of it, dream of it, and live on that idea. Let the brain, muscles, nerves, every part of your body, be full of that idea, and just leave every other idea alone.

  22. Steve Jame

    Sun Dec 07 04:39:58 GMT 2014

    Great post i must say and thanks for the information. Education is definitely a sticky subject. However, is still among the leading topics of our time. I appreciate your post and look forward to more.

  23. Steve Jame

    Tue Dec 09 17:20:10 GMT 2014

    Hi, I just bought this book for Kindle, but I can’t find the code!! Can anyone tell me where exactly is it? Thanks!!!

  24. Steve Jame

    Tue Dec 09 16:54:09 GMT 2014

    The deliberate attempt to contact the spirit of a deceased person is known as necromancy, or in spiritism as a séance.
    diabetes miracle cure dr. robert evans examples