Subscribe to Granta today

The Reader and Technology


Photo by Patrick Feller.

My Futuristic Past

I was born on 20 August 1968 – eleven months to the day before the first Apollo Moon Landing. The Space Age was always something to which I aspired rather than belonged.

For several years, between approximately 1976 and 1979, I wasn’t interested in anything earthbound. The two most important films of my boyhood were Star Wars, which showed me where I wanted to be, and Close Encounters of the Third Kind, which showed me a possible means of getting there.

In preference to Ampthill, Bedfordshire in 1979, I would have taken any technological dystopia. There was no armed rebellion against Margaret Thatcher, and even if there had been it would not have involved laser guns.

A couple of years ago, I spent three months playing World of Warcraft – partly as research for a short story I was writing, mostly because I became addicted to it. This convinced me of one thing: If the computer games which exist now had existed back in 1979 I would not have read any books, I think; I would not have seen writing as an adequate entertainment; I would not have seen going outdoors as sufficiently interesting to bother with.

Similarly, I find it difficult to understand why any eleven-year-old of today would be sufficiently bored to turn inward for entertainment.

This raises the question as to how future writers will come about, without ‘silence, exile and cunning’ – without the need for these things?

I was formed, as a writer, by the boredom of the place in which I lived. Philip Larkin said ‘not the place’s fault’ – but in my case, I think it was. And then, the being taken out of the first place into another place (boarding school) where I was unable to have any privacy. This developed a mania for privacy in me, which began to come out as poetry, as a diary. It’s not that I didn’t do these things before – they just became essentials for self-creating, self-preservation. That’s how I read myself, anyway.

The Reader and Technology

Literature isn’t alien to technology, literature is technological to begin with.

Literature depends on technology – a society needs to be able to do more than subsist before it produces a literature. An oral culture, yes, that is possible – but I am referring specifically to words on the page, words on the screen.

The internet connection offers all of us the constant temptation of snippets, of trivia. We don’t live, as other writers did in the past, without these particular temptations. They had their own temptations: Byron wasn’t undistracted. Yet there were greater acres of emptiness, surely. Travel took forever. Winters isolated. Boredom was there as a resource for daydreaming, trancing out.

I think writers will continue to occur but technology and its trivia will cause us to lose something, just as we lost something when we lost the classical education. We write worse because we cannot write classical prose. Yet classical prose is useless for describing the world of 2012, the world that is there – ready to buzz – in your pocket or bag.

Our perceptions outrun the sedentary sentence by much too much; just as we listen to mp3s to hear what an album would sound like were we actually to sit down and listen to it, so we skim-read the classic books to get a sense of what they would be like were we to sit down and dwell on them.

Readers more accustomed to screens – web pages, iPhone displays – will scan a page of text for its contents, rather than experience it in a There was no armed rebellion against Margaret Thatcher, and even if there had been it would not have involved laser guns. gradual linear top-left to bottom-right way. This will make for increased speed and decreased specificity. These readers will be half-distracted even as they read; their visual field will include other things than just the text, because they won’t feel happy unless those things are there. A writer of long, doubling-back sentences such as Henry James will be incomprehensible to them. They won’t be grammatically equipped to deal with him. They won’t be neurologically capable of reading him. Their eyes will photograph fields rather than, as ours do, or did, follow tracks.

This scanning approach will have a bad effect on sentence structure. For these readers, the fact they are reading bassackwardly – constructed sequences of words won’t matter. They won’t even notice. As long as the content is there for them somewhere on the page, the job of writing will have been done.

Perhaps future writers will, therefore, create vague fields of possible meaning; more Charles Olson than Ezra Pound. The exact sequence of sounds, the precise inflection of grammar – these things will seem prissy. We will be back to the eighteenth century, pre-Flaubert.

Isaac Babel’s famous sentence from his story ‘Guy de Maupassant’: ‘No iron spike can pierce a human heart as icily as a period in the right place.’ – prissy.

The Novel and Connectivity

The people novels have conventionally been written about are gradually ceasing to exist.

Novels have always belonged to aristocrats of time; not, I say, merely to aristocrats, although they have been disproportionately represented, Our perceptions outrun the sedentary sentence by much too much but to those subjects who have freedom of choice about how to act within time. The Fordist factory-line workers, performing a repetitive task all day, cannot interest the novel for more than a few moments whilst they are at work. It is only when the machine stops that the story begins. (David Foster Wallace’s The Pale King attempts to make a novel out of the dead time of insanely repetitive deskwork; and it fails, at least in the form of it he left us.)

Proposition: ‘The human race is no longer sufficently bored with life to be distracted by an art form as boring as the novel.’

Perhaps novels will continue, but instead of the machine it will be the connectivity that stops, or becomes secondary.

What we’re going to see more and more of is the pseudo-contemporary novel – in which characters are, for some reason, cut off from one another, technologically cut off. Already, many contemporary novels avoid the truly contemporary (which is hyperconnectivity).

The basic plots of Western Literature depend on separation by distance – Odysseus separated from Penelope; the Odyssey doesn’t exist if Odysseus can catch an easyJet flight home, or text Penelope’s Blackberry. Joyce’s Ulysses doesn’t exist if Bloom can do his day’s business from a laptop in a Temple Bar coffeeshop.

I don’t want to overemphasize this. You could imagine a similar anxiety over how the telephone would undermine fiction. Perhaps it is just a matter of acceleration. But I don’t think I am alone in already being weary of characters who make their great discoveries whilst sitting in front of a computer screen. If for example a character, by diligent online research and persistent emailing, finds out one day – after a ping in their inbox – who their father really is, isn’t that a story hardly worth telling? Watching someone at a computer is dull. Watching someone play even the most exciting computer game is dull. You, reading this now, are not something any writer would want to write about for more than a sentence.

The Future

In the Preface to Volume 15 of the New York Edition, Henry James writes about ‘operative irony’. It’s a long quote, but try to stick with it because it may contain the whole future of the novel.

‘I have already mentioned the particular rebuke once addressed me on all this ground, the question of where on earth, where roundabout us at this hour, I had “found” my Neil Paradays, my Ralph Limberts, my Hugh Verekers and other such supersubtle fry. I was reminded then, as I have said, that these represented eminent cases fell to the ground, as by their foolish weight, unless I could give chapter and verse for the eminence. I was reduced to confessing I couldn’t, and yet must repeat again here how little I was so abashed. On going over these The basic plots of Western Literature depend on separation by distance – Odysseus separated from Penelope; the Odyssey doesn’t exist if Odysseus can catch an easyJet flight home things I see, to our critical edification, exactly why – which was because I was able to plead that my postulates, my animating presences, were all, to their great enrichment, their intensification of value, ironic; the strength of applied irony being surely in the sincerities, the lucidities, the utilities that stand behind it. When it’s not a campaign, of a sort, on behalf of the something better (better than the obnoxious, the provoking object) that blessedly, as is assumed, might be, it’s not worth speaking of. But this is exactly what we mean by operative irony. It implies and projects the possible other case, the case rich and edifying where the actuality is pretentious and vain. So it plays its lamp; so, essentially, it carries that smokeless flame, which makes clear, with all the rest, the good cause that guides it. My application of which remarks is that the studies here collected have their justification in the ironic spirit, the spirit expressed by my being able to reply promptly enough to my friend: “If the life about us for the last thirty years refuses warrant for these examples, then so much the worse for that life. The constatation would be so deplorable that instead of making it we must dodge it: there are decencies that in the name of the general self-respect we must take for granted, there’s a kind of rudimentary intellectual honour to which we must, in the interest of civilization, at least pretend.” But I must really reproduce the whole passion of my retort.’

In the future, all novels will invoke a kind of operative irony; post-Twitter, post-whatever-comes-after-what-comes-after-Twitter. Who are these ‘supersubtle fry’, your characters, who have all this time in which to become rich, deep selfhoods? Where do you find these interesting subjects of yours?

Or, as Henry James appears to us, so we will appear to the readers of the near future: existing in a different, slow-flowing time that they will need to make an extreme effort of deceleration to access.

I think – as a result of all this – there will be great nostalgia for the pre-trivial age, not even to mention the pre-genetic manipulation age.

Literature can accommodate nostalgia, but only as a houseguest; if nostalgia becomes the landlord, architect and psychoanalyst, literature will have to evict itself. ■

Comments (39)

You need to create an account or log in to comment.

  1. liyucmh

    Sat Jun 09 09:21:28 BST 2012

    This comment has been removed by the moderators.

  2. Siddharthya

    Fri Apr 13 06:29:52 BST 2012

    When I read the title I wondered if this would be yet another eulogy to "old world charm". Even though I admittedly am very fond of the said charm, it does tend to get repetitive.

    Glad this piece is tinged with a lot more reasoning.

  3. Avijeet Das

    Thu Apr 12 13:26:02 BST 2012

    Wonderfully written.Informative and interesting.

  4. rudy

    Sun Apr 15 15:26:25 BST 2012

    If ". . . trancing out.", lay behind the foundation of literature, maybe literature isn't worth much.

    Physicists might now have an answer for the progression of time; It's there to outrun the fatuity of our past.

  5. Anglesey Girl

    Wed Apr 25 10:15:56 BST 2012

    More urban pseud stuff. Not everyone lives in London with an iPhone glued to their hand, not everyone even has English as their first language. I do find it curious when I visit London to hear the abbreviated speak there, littered with references to brand names. But all of life is not there. You need to get out of town more.

  6. salinger53

    Fri Apr 13 21:07:25 BST 2012

    An interesting point, but I think that technology within literature should not be considered a limitation as such. Look at Gary Shteyngart's Super Sad True Love Story.

    That book seemed to point to the inhumanity which was caused by technology, yet it also demonstrated the inability of escaping that humanity. I don't want to spoil the book for anyone that hasn't read it, but I think that technology poses a great opportunity for writers to explore the new space in which people exist in light of the advent of new technology.

  7. Laryssa

    Mon Apr 23 14:25:51 BST 2012

    I thought this piece was very smartly written, and it made me consider my own origins as a writer. As a writing instructor, I'm always worried about the future of my students. I wrote a blog post in response. Check it out!

  8. bankrupty filing

    Wed Aug 28 17:14:18 BST 2013

    The article's content rich variety which make us move for our mood after reading this article. surprise, here you will find what you want! Recently, I found some wedsites which commodity is colorful of fashion. Such as that worth you to see. Believe me these websites won’t let you down.

  9. peter

    Wed Feb 25 07:31:05 GMT 2015

    I was looking for this kind of information for some time and finally found it here // buy bombshell bee pollen weight loss

  10. davy jones

    Fri Feb 13 07:49:04 GMT 2015

  11. agenbola33

    Sun Nov 03 08:51:19 GMT 2013

    Always feeling under the weather? Always not in the mood to be around others and have a good time?

  12. agenbola33

    Sun Nov 03 08:52:19 GMT 2013

    If you’re suffering from prolonged sadness for quite some time now, you should face these bouts of depression and get yourself diagnosed by a psychiatrist, they’re doctors who can actually help you out with your problem.

  13. agenbola33

    Sun Nov 03 08:56:01 GMT 2013 Depression oftentimes can easily get in the way of an individual’s daily activities and his or her’s normal functions, one’s zest for life can quickly and easily dissipate due to depression.

  14. agenbola33

    Sun Nov 03 08:56:32 GMT 2013 And in place of an individual’s sunny disposition is more or less a person who hates his or herself, having no self-confidence, trying to isolate one’s self from the world and basically just not caring about living any more. More so, a person suffering

  15. agenbola33

    Sun Nov 03 08:57:08 GMT 2013

    from depression isn’t the only one who’s going to suffer from this destructive illness, his or her loved ones are sure to follow suit. By seeing the individual grow through rough patches, basically not caring about anything or anyone anymore, it’s highly likely that not only will depression one’s relationship with one’s self but with his or her loved ones too.

  16. khani

    Tue Dec 03 18:58:13 GMT 2013

    Technology is such evolve in our life we have left reading books either just go for ebooks online

  17. mull

    Fri Dec 06 22:14:50 GMT 2013

    I think is very important beetwen read and technology, but technology is most simple, and book can lost if you dont keep carefully <a href=""></a>

  18. Mohit Varma

    Sun Dec 22 03:13:09 GMT 2013

    I have a Kindle DX, and I read some technical books. It has a built-in pdf reader. Good and bad things has e-ink display. Eyestrain is good-never happened. Bad-it is not very flexible search through documents is slow and poor zoom function, slowly turning the pages.

  19. TomWalker

    Sat Dec 28 12:56:48 GMT 2013

    The two most important films of my boyhood were Star Wars, which showed me where I wanted to be, and Close Encounters of the Third Kind, which showed me a possible means of getting there

  20. qwfr3

    Mon Mar 02 07:27:36 GMT 2015

    This black sweater matches the one Rob Ford was on this photo in which he was with two black men, a cliché which launched its allegations wrong crowd and his drug use.

  21. iGamble247

    Sun Apr 06 09:20:09 BST 2014

    La literatura puede dar cabida a la nostalgia, pero sólo como un invitado; si la nostalgia se convierte en el propietario, arquitecto y psicoanalista, la literatura tendrá que desalojar a sí mismo.

  22. Highline Residences

    Mon Mar 03 08:27:51 GMT 2014

    For vehicle owners, it takes less than 5 minutes to drive to the business hub and vibrant Orchard Road shopping district via Central Expressway (CTE).

  23. Jurong

    Sun Mar 02 14:21:47 GMT 2014

    the best place to go is where the old-meets-new world charm which is equivalent to the reader and technology

  24. Lakeville Condo Jurong

    Thu Feb 27 03:33:48 GMT 2014

    Lakeville will be accessible via Jurong East MRT. Commuting to the Bukit Timah Area as well as the city area is therefore very convenient. It is also right beside J Cube, Westgate and Jem. IMM Jurong as well as Jurong Country Club are also within a short walk.

  25. Santorini

    Thu Feb 27 01:32:49 GMT 2014

    For vehicle owners, it takes less than 30 minutes to drive to the city area, via Pan Island Expressway (PIE).

  26. The Crest

    Tue Feb 04 03:06:52 GMT 2014

    well said toby, you deserve an award for this exceptionally piece of work.

  27. dewafitnes

    Wed Apr 30 04:29:01 BST 2014

    World of Warcraft is one of my favorite games. I agree. I have read all your post. I think it´s really interesting.

  28. Jurong

    Mon Feb 24 05:06:33 GMT 2014

    reader and technology... we always read at one corner of the lake as we are living opposite the lake at and after that we will be back to reality by using our gadgets to communicate with the rest of the world..

  29. Jurong

    Tue Mar 18 12:25:15 GMT 2014

    yes we read and with technology at the forefront, we are moving ahead with as the pioneer batch with the first mover advantage as it is the only freehold property whereas the rest are leasehold when released...

  30. Jurong

    Thu Feb 20 03:06:28 GMT 2014

    i've actually written about this using my aged blackberry in a coffeshop at venture avenue just like you do and if you are keen, do find out more from my site at

  31. Najib

    Mon Mar 02 21:37:56 GMT 2015

    There is too many amine sites where you can watch anime and read manga online like Naruto, Bealch, Tokyo Ghoul and Fairy Tail, the best anime manga site is there is thousands of brand new manga you can read everyday..

  32. reginiahandsaker

    Mon Jan 12 05:26:00 GMT 2015

    A very nice and good post This. I really like it very much. Keep This quality of your work on articles going on and please do not let the quality of your articles fail to bad.

  33. hrw5

    Tue Feb 24 11:06:42 GMT 2015

    Het uiteindelijke doel zou zijn om te helpen zes inspecteurs in dienst van de BTM identificeren automobilisten die te maken illegale transport en schroei hun voertuigen. "Maar we zullen ervoor zorgen om te voldoen aan de wetten," voegde de bestuurder.

  34. swdwd

    Sat Feb 21 08:11:58 GMT 2015

    The City of Montreal will pay $ 1.8 million to a recycling company after a fire in June 2011 which completely destroyed the building.

  35. swdwd

    Sat Feb 21 08:12:43 GMT 2015

    The events date back to June 8, 2011, firefighters were called to intervene to put out a fire in a paper recycling truck.

  36. swd3f

    Mon Feb 23 14:41:18 GMT 2015

    Ce est le 29 octobre, une journée d'automne gris, et les élites établies Washington sont rassemblés en face de la cathédrale nationale: de hauts responsables politiques, les éditeurs et les meilleurs journalistes passés et présents. Ils sont venus pour enterrer Ben Bradlee, une légende dans le monde du journalisme. Il a été rédacteur en chef lorsque le message a découvert le scandale du Watergate dans les années 1970, ramenant alors président Richard Nixon et assurer une place permanente pour le papier dans les livres d'histoire américains.